Call to atention about using hash functions as content indexers (SCM saga)

[Pedro Larroy]

Hi

I had a quick look at the source of GIT tonight, I'd like to warn you
about the use of hash functions as content indexers.

As probably you are aware, hash functions such as SHA-1 are surjective not
bijective (1-to-1 map), so they have collisions. Here one can argue
about the low probability of such a collision, I won't get into
subjetive valorations of what probability of collision is tolerable for
me and what is not. 

I my humble opinion, choosing deliberately, as a design decision, a
method such as this one, that in some cases could corrupt data in a
silent and very hard to detect way, is not very good. One can also argue
that the probability of data getting corrupted in the disk, or whatever
could be higher than that of the collision, again this is not valid
comparison, since the fact that indexing by hash functions without
additional checking could make data corruption legal between the
reasonable working parameters of the program is very dangerous.

And by the way, I've read
http://www.usenix.org/events/hotos03/tech/full_papers/henson/henson_html/node15.html

and I don't agree with it. Asides from the "avalanche effect" the
properties of a good hash function is that distributes well the entropy
between the output bits, so probably, although the inputs are not
random, the pdf change in the outputs would be small, otherwise it would
be easier to find collision by differential or statistical methods.

Last, hash functions should be only used to check data integrity, and
that's the reason of the "avalanche effect", so even single bit errors
are propagated and it's effect is very noticeable at the output.

Regards.

-- 
Pedro Larroy Tovar | Linux & Network consultant |  pedro%larroy.com 
Make debian mirrors with debian-multimirror: http://pedro.larroy.com/deb_mm/
	* Las patentes de programación son nocivas para la innovación * 
				http://proinnova.hispalinux.es/
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/