I can imagine other projects wanting to do runtime muxing on those pins.mode.How does this interact with the pinctrl driver that Laxman justThanks for pointing this out. Given this:
sent for Palmas?
[PATCH 0/2] pinctrl: palmas: add pincontrol driver
+- ti,palams-enable-dvfs1: Enable DVFS1. Configure pins for DVFS1
mode.+- ti,palams-enable-dvfs2: Enable DVFS2. Configure pins for DVFS2pinctrl driver.In linux-next (where I based my work), yes, those two propertiesI think his work already encompasses what my patch is supposed to do.OK, that's simple!
Abandoning this patch.
Are the existing ti,mux-pad1/ti,mux-pad2 properties already in the
binding redundant with Laxman's pinctrl driver?
already exist, and as far as I understand it, are redundant with Laxman's
I expect those properties will go away with Laxman's pinctrl driver.Except those properties have been there for many kernel revisions and are
an ABI and hence can't be removed, although I noticed that they got
renamed recently, and of course we aren't technically being strict about this
Re: the complete pinctrl driver: is anything outside the Palmas going to need
to reprogram the Palmas pinctrl HW at run-time? Are the functions that can
be routed to the pins just static configuration for PMIC features, or might
other generic (non-Palmas) drivers use those pins for something? If not,
perhaps it's be simpler to just add your ti,mux-pad3 property and be done.
These pins can serve as GPIOs, or can be programmed for special functions.
For my particular scenario, I just need to statically set that particular mux
register (the power-on default value is not suitable for what we want to
do, namely to use the GPIO_6 pin as an actual GPIO pin). If the existing
ti,mux-pad1 and ti,mux-pad2 properties are to stay, in the spirit of not changing
the existing ABI, then sure, we can make a case for adding the missing one
(ti,mux-pad3) for completeness. In this case, if the palmas PMIC's pin
configuration can be statically set at start of day, one won't even need to
instantiate the palmas pinctrl driver at all, and with the addition of ti,mux-pad3,
the pin configuration control will actually be complete.