Re: [PATCH v3] zsmalloc: fix migrate_zspage-zs_free race condition
From: Vlastimil Babka
Date: Mon Jan 18 2016 - 02:54:09 EST
On 18.1.2016 8:39, Sergey Senozhatsky wrote:
> On (01/18/16 16:11), Minchan Kim wrote:
>>> so, even if clear_bit_unlock/test_and_set_bit_lock do smp_mb or
>>> barrier(), there is no corresponding barrier from record_obj()->WRITE_ONCE().
>>> so I don't think WRITE_ONCE() will help the compiler, or am I missing
>> We need two things
>> 2. memory barrier.
>> As compiler barrier, WRITE_ONCE works to prevent store tearing here
>> by compiler.
>> However, if we omit unpin_tag here, we lose memory barrier(e,g, smp_mb)
>> so another CPU could see stale data caused CPU memory reordering.
> oh... good find! lost release semantic of unpin_tag()...
Ah, release semantic, good point indeed. OK then we need the v2 approach again,
with WRITE_ONCE() in record_obj(). Or some kind of record_obj_release() with
release semantic, which would be a bit more effective, but I guess migration is
not that critical path to be worth introducing it.