Re: [PATCH v10 3/4] x86, mce: Add __mcsafe_copy()

[Luck, Tony]

> You can save yourself this MOV here in what is, I'm assuming, the
> general likely case where @src is aligned and do:
> 
>         /* check for bad alignment of source */
>         testl $7, %esi
>         /* already aligned? */
>         jz 102f
> 
>         movl %esi,%ecx
>         subl $8,%ecx
>         negl %ecx
>         subl %ecx,%edx
> 0:      movb (%rsi),%al
>         movb %al,(%rdi)
>         incq %rsi
>         incq %rdi
>         decl %ecx
>         jnz 0b

The "testl $7, %esi" just checks the low three bits ... it doesn't
change %esi.  But the code from the "subl $8" on down assumes that
%ecx is a number in [1..7] as the count of bytes to copy until we
achieve alignment.

So your "movl %esi,%ecx" needs to be somthing that just copies the
low three bits and zeroes the high part of %ecx.  Is there a cute
way to do that in x86 assembler?

> Why aren't we pushing %r12-%r15 on the stack after the "jz 17f" above
> and using them too and thus copying a whole cacheline in one go?
> 
> We would need to restore them when we're done with the cacheline-wise
> shuffle, of course.

I copied that loop from arch/x86/lib/copy_user_64.S:__copy_user_nocache()
I guess the answer depends on whether you generally copy enough
cache lines to save enough time to cover the cost of saving and
restoring those registers.

-Tony