Re: A udev rule to serve the change event of ACPI container?

[YASUAKI ISHIMATSU]

On 08/02/2017 01:49 AM, joeyli wrote:
> Hi YASUAKI,
> 
> On Tue, Aug 01, 2017 at 03:21:38PM -0400, YASUAKI ISHIMATSU wrote:
>> Hi Joey,
>>
>> On 07/23/2017 05:18 AM, joeyli wrote:
> [...snip]
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>> At least Yasuaki raised similar behavior for container in 2013.
>>>> It's similar to the DVD player case, user space application needs
>>>> to do something then trigger children offline and ejection of
>>>> container.
>>>>
>>>> Base on Yasuaki's explanation, the reason of that he requested the
>>>> userland ejection approach is that he got memory hot-remove problem
>>>> in 2013. Maybe his problem is already fixed by your patches in current
>>>> mainline.
>>>>
>>>> Hi Yasuaki, could you please check that your memory hot-remove problem
>>>> is fixed on mainline kernel?  
>>
>> I cannot remember what I mentioned in 2013. Could you tell me url of lkml archive.
>>
> 

> Here: https://lkml.org/lkml/2013/11/28/520

Thank you for specifying the URL. In the URL, I wrote the following problems:

>   1. easily fail
>      My container device has CPU device and Memory device, and maximum size of
>      memory is 3Tbyte. In my environment, hot removing container device fails
>      on offlining memory if memory is used by application.
>      I think if offlininig memory, we must retly to offline memory several
>      times.

I think the issue still remains. If process keeps accessing memory, offlining
the memory easily fails with EBUSY.

Thanks,
Yasuaki Ishimatsu


> 
> In the mail, you mentioned two problems. But there have no detail about
> those issues, and no root causes. We don't know why kernel should relies
> on user space to complete the hot removing process for container.
> 
> Thank a lot!
> Joey Lee
>