Re: [PATCH 2/3] namei: implement AT_THIS_ROOT chroot-like path resolution

From: Bruce Fields
Date: Mon Oct 01 2018 - 09:56:01 EST


On Mon, Oct 01, 2018 at 03:44:28PM +1000, Aleksa Sarai wrote:
> On 2018-09-29, Jann Horn <jannh@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> > The problem is what happens if a folder you are walking through is
> > concurrently moved out of the chroot. Consider the following scenario:
> >
> > You attempt to open "C/../../etc/passwd" under the root "/A/B".
> > Something else concurrently moves /A/B/C to /A/C. This can result in
> > the following:
> >
> > 1. You start the path walk and reach /A/B/C.
> > 2. The other process moves /A/B/C to /A/C. Your path walk is now at /A/C.
> > 3. Your path walk follows the first ".." up into /A. This is outside
> > the process root, but you never actually encountered the process root,
> > so you don't notice.
> > 4. Your path walk follows the second ".." up to /. Again, this is
> > outside the process root, but you don't notice.
> > 5. Your path walk walks down to /etc/passwd, and the open completes
> > successfully. You now have an fd pointing outside your chroot.
> >
> > If the root of your walk is below an attacker-controlled directory,
> > this of course means that you lose instantly. If you point the root of
> > the walk at a directory out of which a process in the container
> > wouldn't be able to move the file, you're probably kinda mostly fine -
> > as long as you know, for certain, that nothing else on the system
> > would ever do that. But I still wouldn't feel good about that.
>
> Please correct me if I'm wrong here (this is the first patch I've
> written for VFS). Isn't the retry/LOOKUP_REVAL code meant to handle this

No.

...
> Speaking naively, doesn't it make sense to invalidate the walk if a path
> component was modified? Or is this something that would be far too
> costly with little benefit?

Lookups and renames can definitely proceed in parallel, and yes I
suspect it would be difficult to get good performance and guaranteed
forward progress if you required lookup of the full path to be atomic
with respect to renames.

--b.