Re: [RFC PATCH 0/5] leds: Add DT node finding and parsing to core

[Enrico Weigelt, metux IT consult]

On 18.11.19 11:38, Vaittinen, Matti wrote:

Hi,

>> a) existing DT's (in the field) become incompatible with newer
>>    kernel versions
> 
> This was my main concern. This of course would not mean that we could
> not take this approach for new LED controller drivers - but that would
> (probably) lead to dual led registration interface 

Maybe just a flag for that ? Perhaps the driver could also specify a
list of node names for the LEDs, so led-core can do the lookup for them.

>> b) existing userlands that rely on speicific LED names become
>>    incomatible with newer kernel versions.
> 
> I didn't even think this far, but yes, I see... LED node name might be
> reflected in user-space LED name. I won't start arguing if this is sane
> or not - this is what we seem to be living with today :)

Especially in embedded world, this can really make sense: applications
just use a defined LED name, no matter which board it's running on.
Convention over configuration.

Personally, I also like to use LED subsystem as frontend for things like
gpio-driven relais, etc, and assign semantically fitting names instead
of "technical" ones,

> I didn't invest too much of time on this yet - but at first glimpse it
> seemed that at least some of the drivers did use reg - property with
> fixed value to do the matching. Those could set the property name to
> 'reg' and value to 'X' and leave the DT node lookup and common property
> parsing to the LED core. If my patch won't get too big objection (and
> if no fatal flaws are found from the idea) - then I might try and find
> the time to do some follow-up patches simplifying existing LED
> drivers...

Sounds good :)


--mtx

-- 
Dringender Hinweis: aufgrund existenzieller Bedrohung durch "Emotet"
sollten Sie *niemals* MS-Office-Dokumente via E-Mail annehmen/Ãffenen,
selbst wenn diese von vermeintlich vertrauenswÃrdigen Absendern zu
stammen scheinen. Andernfalls droht Totalschaden.
---
Hinweis: unverschlÃsselte E-Mails kÃnnen leicht abgehÃrt und manipuliert
werden ! FÃr eine vertrauliche Kommunikation senden Sie bitte ihren
GPG/PGP-SchlÃssel zu.
---
Enrico Weigelt, metux IT consult
Free software and Linux embedded engineering
info@xxxxxxxxx -- +49-151-27565287