Re: BusLogic + SMP == broke

Brian Macy (bmacy@sunshinecomputing.com)
Wed, 08 Sep 1999 22:35:52 -0700


Stephen Frost wrote:
>
> Get any funny kernel errors on the screen when these locks happened?
> I've got a BT958D in an SMP machine, and basically every day, damn near EVERY
> day, it'll lock on me w/ a message bitching about a scsi error or something,
> I'd have to go look it up again...

Not so lucky... what happens nearly every time:
- Do a preview scan (xsane, net SANE, or xscanimage)
- Do a scan at 300dpi
- Stops part way into the scan and the app doing the scanning locks
- About 30seconds later the entire machine locks solid, no message, no
anything

>From looking at the driver, it isn't doing proper locking. The only
thing using spinlocks is the ISR itself... which is of little use since
the other side of the command queue'ing isn't locked. There are stubs
for non-ISR locks but the function are NOPs. If you do make the
functions call spinlocks the driver locks up on detection (my guess is
deadlocking on the spinlock). I'm not sure this is the real problem as
I'd expect kernel oops over poor resource contention.

I figured I'd take Doug's suggestion and look at the aic7xxx driver and
see if I can figure out how I can use it as a model to rewrite the
BusLogic driver... or I may look at the new Mylex DAC960 driver since it
uses a similar model but appears to at least attempt to use proper
locking. Driver writing is pretty new to me so I may just break-down,
give up, and get a new card.

BTW you wouldn't happen to have a Tyan motherboard would you?

Brian Macy

-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@vger.rutgers.edu
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/