Re: [PATCH v6 0/4] Switch Arm SMCCC firmware services to an SMCCC bus

[Aneesh Kumar K . V]

Hi Greg,

"Aneesh Kumar K.V (Arm)" <aneesh.kumar@xxxxxxxxxx> writes:

> As discussed here:
> https://lore.kernel.org/all/20250728135216.48084-12-aneesh.kumar@xxxxxxxxxx
>
> The earlier CCA guest support used an arm-cca-dev platform device as a pure
> software anchor for the TSM class device. That platform device did not
> correspond to a DT/ACPI described device, MMIO range, interrupt, or other
> platform resource; it existed only to make the CCA guest driver bind and to
> place the resulting TSM device in the driver model. The same pattern also
> exists for smccc_trng. Creating separate platform devices for such
> SMCCC-discovered features is misleading, because those features are not
> independent platform devices.
>
> This series adds an Arm SMCCC bus for services discovered through the SMCCC
> firmware interface. The bus provides SMCCC device and driver registration
> helpers, name-based matching, uevent modalias generation, and a sysfs modalias
> attribute. SMCCC service drivers can use MODULE_DEVICE_TABLE(arm_smccc, ...)
> to emit arm_smccc:<name> aliases, allowing userspace to autoload service
> drivers when the SMCCC core registers matching firmware-service devices.
>
> The series then moves SMCCC TRNG and the Arm CCA guest RSI service off the
> platform bus. When the SMCCC core discovers the corresponding firmware
> service, it registers an arm-smccc device for that service. The hwrng
> arm_smccc_trng driver and the Arm CCA guest TSM provider are converted to
> SMCCC drivers that bind to those discovered devices.
>
> The old arm-cca-dev platform device has also been used by userspace as a Realm
> guest indicator. Removing it without a replacement would leave userspace
> depending on an internal driver-binding device. This series therefore adds
> /sys/firmware/cca/realm_guest as a stable, architecture-provided ABI for
> detecting whether the kernel is running as an Arm CCA Realm guest, and then
> removes the dummy arm-cca-dev platform-device registration.
>


Gentle ping. Based on your feedback in [1], I reworked the series to use
an SMCCC bus, with smccc-trng and arm-cca-dev represented as devices on
that bus. Could you let me know whether this approach addresses your
concerns?

[1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/2026051451-comfort-museum-4d2a@gregkh/

-aneesh