Re: [PATCH net v2 2/2] net: ngbe: clear DRV_LOAD bit when ngbe_open() fails

[Zhang Yunfei]

Resend with the full Cc list; the previous reply inadvertently dropped
the Cc recipients.

Hi Breno,

Not silly at all -- txgbe's approach is indeed cleaner, and you read it
right: wx_control_hw(wx, true) lives at the top of txgbe_up_complete()
(txgbe_main.c:160), so txgbe's open error paths never have to unwind
the bit.

For ngbe I kept the claim where the vendor put it (top of ngbe_open())
and added the missing rollback, because moving the claim into
ngbe_up_complete() changes the driver-firmware handshake timing: the
whole setup/configure window would then run while the NCSI/OOB
firmware still believes it owns the port. Whether ngbe's management
firmware tolerates that window is a firmware-contract question I
cannot answer from the code alone (txgbe is a different product line),
so Jiawen/Mengyuan are better placed to judge it. Deferring the claim
into ngbe_up_complete() would look like the cleaner long-term shape;
this patch only closes the existing inconsistency.

Thanks for the suggestion!

Zhang Yunfei