Re: Voluntary Preemption + concurent games

[Nick Piggin]

Aivils wrote:
> Hi All!
>
> 	I still use in my home minicomputer under Linux, where
> 3 users use one CPU/RAM , but own video.
> 	By default 2.6.XX task scheduler don' t like concurent applications
> at all. 2.6.XX task scheduler allways raise on top of tasks only one
> task and keep it on top until user stop it.
> 	This rule is very unwanted for minicomputers, because multile
> local users will use one CPU and feel lucky.

The CPU scheduler in 2.6 does a lot of special casing in order
to boost interactivity. This can cause weird behaviour and
imbalances like you are seeing when multiple things are running.

> 	As point of reference i use 2.4.XX tack scheduler, which is very
> "righteous" and allways give CPU time for all tasks. Under 2.4.XX
> concurent games run smooth.
>
> 	2.6.XX non-preemptive and 2.6.XX voluntary-preemptive task
> scheduling looks very similar. My gamer' s eye report me very
> thiny and very subjective difference - preferable is voluntary-preemtive.
> Anyway all concurent CPU intensive tasks should be started with
> nice -n +19 game-bin . Any other nice value remake one of
> running game to slide show or both running games became slide show.
>
> 	So we should start any game with nice +19. In is this set goes in
> netscape and konqueror because of java web-chat and games.
>
> 	At least voluntary-preemptive allow me move away from 2.4.26

2.6's CPU scheduler gives nice +19 tasks shorter timeslices, so you
are effectively giving everything better latency.

I have a patchset for 2.6 with some scheduler changes that you might
like to try, here: http://www.kerneltrap.org/~npiggin/2.6.7-np8/, and
let me know how it goes if you do try it. If you need any help getting
it going, please email me privately.
-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/