Re: [BK] disconnected operation

From: Martin Dalecki
Date: Sun Dec 26 2004 - 15:23:17 EST



On 2004-12-26, at 18:19, Larry McVoy wrote:
For James, could you do a little debugging please? Run the following
when you are plugged in and it works and also when it doesn't:

bk getuser
bk getuser -r
bk gethost
bk gethost -r
bk dotbk

We'll track it down and fix it if it is a problem on our end. This stuff
is supposed to work, we certainly haven't intentionally caused a problem.

Larry, that's futile, please trust me, you really can't fix this conveniently
and properly, without changing the principles of operation. nscd, mDNSresponder,
dhclient, glibc, NDIS, netinfo, some NAT, proxy, OpenDirectory, and so on, the whole gang,
gosh even /etc/hostname will *always* get you sometime if you intend to
accommodate mobile users. Eee... did I say mobile users, Well let's use the proper
buzz-word. *Roaming* users. Take it as a given: The nice shiny easy days of BSD4-Net
release are long past and gone. A hostname simply isn't a fixed attribute of a host anymore.
Setting a host name has nowadays more the character of a prayer or christmas wish to Santa,
then any setup measure.

I really recommend that you give him a cookie and check if he still didn't eat it
next time you meet him. (So don't give him a crispy well smelling one...)
Or even better please do yourself the favor and go straight the whole way down to
SASL, TSL and so on... There where already people around there with similar problems before.
(www.beepcore.org comes in to mind for something quite modern and not directly
Java/XML/SOAP/bla bla bloated...)

-
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/