dnotify/inotify and vfs questions

[Asser Femø]

Hi,

I'm currently implementing change notification support for the linux
cifs client as part of Google's Summer of Code program.

In cifs, change notification works pretty much the same as dnotify does
in the kernel, and you cancel the notification by sending a NT_CANCEL
request. 

According to the fcntl manual you can cancel a notification by doing
fcntl(fd, F_NOTIFY, 0) (ie. sending 0 as the notification mask), but
looking in the kernel code fcntl_dirnotify() immediately calls
dnotify_flush() with neither telling the vfs module about it. Is there a
reason for this?  Otherwise I'd propose calling
filp->f_op->dir_notify(filp, 0) at some point in this scenario.

Regarding inotify, inotify_add_watch doesn't seem to pass on the request
either, which works fine for local filesystem operations as they call
fsnotify_* functions every time, but that isn't really feasible for
filesystems like cifs because we'd have to request change notification
on everything. Is there plans for implementing a mechanism to let vfs
modules get watch requests too?

cheers,
Asser

Attachment: pgp00000.pgp
Description: PGP signature