Re: [RFC] [PATCH] Memory controller remove control_type feature

[Andrew Morton]

On Fri, 21 Dec 2007 00:23:58 +0530 Balbir Singh <balbir@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> Based on the discussion at http://lkml.org/lkml/2007/12/20/383, it was
> felt that control_type might not be a good thing to implement right away.
> We can add this flexibility at a later point when required.

Gee the memory controller patchset is turning into a mess.

memory-controller-add-documentation.patch
memcgroup-temporarily-revert-swapoff-mod.patch
memory-controller-resource-counters-v7.patch
memory-controller-containers-setup-v7.patch
memory-controller-accounting-setup-v7.patch
memory-controller-memory-accounting-v7.patch
memory-controller-memory-accounting-v7-move-page_assign_page_cgroup-to-vm_bug_on-in-free_hot_cold_page.patch
memory-controller-task-migration-v7.patch
memory-controller-add-per-container-lru-and-reclaim-v7.patch
memory-controller-add-per-container-lru-and-reclaim-v7-memcgroup-fix-try_to_free-order.patch
memory-controller-improve-user-interface.patch
memory-controller-improve-user-interface-memory-controller-enhancements-for-reclaiming-take2-possible-race-fix-in-res_counter.patch
memory-controller-oom-handling-v7.patch
memory-controller-add-switch-to-control-what-type-of-pages-to-limit-v7.patch
memory-controller-make-page_referenced-container-aware-v7.patch
memory-controller-make-charging-gfp-mask-aware.patch
memory-controller-make-charging-gfp-mask-aware-fix.patch
memcgroup-reinstate-swapoff-mod.patch
memory-controller-bug_on.patch
mem-controller-gfp-mask-fix.patch
memcontrol-move-mm_cgroup-to-header-file.patch
memcontrol-move-oom-task-exclusion-to-tasklist.patch
oom-add-sysctl-to-enable-task-memory-dump.patch
kswapd-should-only-wait-on-io-if-there-is-io.patch
bugfix-for-memory-cgroup-controller-charge-refcnt-race-fix.patch
bugfix-for-memory-cgroup-controller-fix-error-handling-path-in-mem_charge_cgroup.patch
bugfix-for-memory-controller-add-helper-function-for-assigning-cgroup-to-page.patch
bugfix-for-memory-cgroup-controller-avoid-pagelru-page-in-mem_cgroup_isolate_pages.patch
bugfix-for-memory-cgroup-controller-avoid-pagelru-page-in-mem_cgroup_isolate_pages-fix.patch
memcgroup-fix-zone-isolation-oom.patch
memcgroup-revert-swap_state-mods.patch
bugfix-for-memory-cgroup-controller-migration-under-memory-controller-fix.patch
#
memory-cgroup-enhancements-fix-zone-handling-in-try_to_free_mem_cgroup_page.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-fix-zone-handling-in-try_to_free_mem_cgroup_page-warning-fix.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-force_empty-interface-for-dropping-all-account-in-empty-cgroup.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-remember-a-page-is-charged-as-page-cache.patch
memory-controller-use-rcu_read_lock-in-mem_cgroup_cache_charge.patch
memcgroup-tidy-up-mem_cgroup_charge_common.patch
memcgroup-fix-hang-with-shmem-tmpfs.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-remember-a-page-is-on-active-list-of-cgroup-or-not.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-add-status-accounting-function-for-memory-cgroup.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-add-status-accounting-function-for-memory-cgroup-checkpatch-fixes.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-add-status-accounting-function-for-memory-cgroup-fix-1.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-add-status-accounting-function-for-memory-cgroup-uninlining.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-add-status-accounting-function-for-memory-cgroup-fix-2.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-add-memorystat-file.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-add-memorystat-file-checkpatch-fixes.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-add-memorystat-file-printk-fix.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-add-pre_destroy-handler.patch
memory-cgroup-enhancements-implicit-force_empty-at-rmdir.patch
#
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-add-scan_global_lru-macro.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-nid-zid-helper-function-for-cgroup.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-per-zone-active-inactive-counter.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-per-zone-active-inactive-counter-memory-controller-enhancements-for-reclaiming-take2-clean-up-remove-unused-variable.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-per-zone-active-inactive-counter-memory-controller-enhancements-for-reclaiming-take2-add-bug_on-in-mem_cgroup_zoneinfo.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-calculate-mapper_ratio-per-cgroup.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-calculate-active-inactive-imbalance-per-cgroup.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-remember-reclaim-priority-in-memory-cgroup.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-remember-reclaim-priority-in-memory-cgroup-fix.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-remember-reclaim-priority-in-memory-cgroup-fix-2.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-calculate-the-number-of-pages-to-be-scanned-per-cgroup.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-modifies-vmscanc-for-isolate-globa-cgroup-lru-activity.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-modifies-vmscanc-for-isolate-globa-cgroup-lru-activity-fix.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-modifies-vmscanc-for-isolate-globa-cgroup-lru-activity-fix-accounting-in-vmscanc-for-memory-controller.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-per-zone-lru-for-cgroup.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-per-zone-lru-for-cgroup-bugfix-for-memory-cgroup-per-zone-struct-allocation.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-per-zone-lru-for-cgroup-memory-controller-enhancements-for-reclaiming-take2-define-free_mem_cgroup_per_zone_info.patch
per-zone-and-reclaim-enhancements-for-memory-controller-take-3-per-zone-lock-for-cgroup.patch
memory-controller-remove-control_type-feature.patch
update-documentation-controller-memorytxt.patch

Hopefully it'll look a bit better once I do a big patch-folding but we
still have patches interesecting everywhere and now we have patches which
add a feature and later ones which take it away again.

But I don't think it's worth the time and risk of a huge
rip-up-and-refactor.

--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/