Re: memory hotplug: hot-remove fails on lowest chunk in ZONE_MOVABLE

[Yasunori Goto]

> On Wed, 2008-07-30 at 12:16 +0900, Yasunori Goto wrote:
> > Well, I didn't mean changing pages_min value. There may be side effect as
> > you are saying.
> > I meant if some pages were MIGRATE_RESERVE attribute when hot-remove are
> > -executing-, their attribute should be changed.
> > 
> > For example, how is like following dummy code?  Is it impossible?
> > (Not only here, some places will have to be modified..)
> 
> Right, this should be possible. I was somewhat wandering from the subject,
> because I noticed that there may be a bigger problem with MIGRATE_RESERVE
> pages in ZONE_MOVABLE, and that we may not want to have them in the first
> place.
> 
> The more memory we add to ZONE_MOVABLE, the less reserved pages will
> remain to the other zones. In setup_per_zone_pages_min(), min_free_kbytes
> will be redistributed to a zone where the kernel cannot make any use of
> it, effectively reducing the available min_free_kbytes. This just doesn't
> sound right. I believe that a similar situation is the reason why highmem
> pages are skipped in the calculation and I think that we need that for
> ZONE_MOVABLE too. Any thoughts on that problem?
> 
> Setting pages_min to 0 for ZONE_MOVABLE, while not capping pages_low
> and pages_high, could be an option. I don't have a sufficient memory
> managment overview to tell if that has negative side effects, maybe
> someone with a deeper insight could comment on that.

At least, pages_min should not be 0. It is used as watermark when
memory shortage situation. If it is 0, kernel will misunderstand
shortage situation. Certainly, pages_min value may be not appropriate value
for ZONE_MOVABLE. But it is not memory-hotplug issue.

True your question is why ZONE_MOVABLE has MIGRATE_RESREVE pages, right?
However, I think it is intended for emergency pool of memory shortage situation
for ZONE_MOVABLE via fallback[]. If not, these MIGRATE_RESERVE pages are not made
originally.
It is why I wrote previous mail.

Mel Gormal-san knows around here very well. He may explain its detail more.

Bye.

-- 
Yasunori Goto 


--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/