Re: [RFC] CPUID usage for interaction between Hypervisors and Linux.
From: H. Peter Anvin
Date: Wed Oct 01 2008 - 14:47:41 EST
Jeremy Fitzhardinge wrote:
H. Peter Anvin wrote:
With a sufficiently large block, we could use fixed points, e.g. by
having each vendor create interfaces in the 0x40SSSSXX range, where
SSSS is the PCI ID they use for PCI devices.
Sure, you could do that, but you'd still want to have a signature in
0x40SSSS00 to positively identify the chunk. And what if you wanted
more than 256 leaves?
What you'd want, at least, is a standard CPUID identification and range
leaf at the top. 256 leaves is a *lot*, though; I'm not saying one
couldn't run out, but it'd be hard. Keep in mind that for large objects
there are "counting" CPUID levels, as much as I personally dislike them,
and one could easily argue that if you're doing something that would
require anywhere near 256 leaves you probably are storing bulk data that
belongs elsewhere.
Of course, if we had some kind of central authority assigning 8-bit IDs
that would be even better, especially since there are tools in the field
which already scan on 64K boundaries. I don't know, though, how likely
it is that we'll have to deal with 256 hypervisors.
Note that I said "create interfaces". It's important that all about
this is who specified the interface -- for "what hypervisor is this"
just use 0x40000000 and disambiguate based on that.
"What hypervisor is this?" isn't a very interesting question; if you're
even asking it then it suggests that something has gone wrong. Its much
more useful to ask "what interfaces does this hypervisor support?", and
enumerating a smallish range of well-known leaves looking for signatures
is the simplest way to do that. (We could use signatures derived from
the PCI vendor IDs which would help with managing that namespace.)
I agree completely, of course (except that "what hypervisor is this"
still has limited usage, especially when it comes to dealing with bug
workarounds. Similar to the way we use CPU vendor IDs and stepping
numbers for physical CPUs.)
-hpa
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at http://www.tux.org/lkml/