Re: [PATCH] serial: imx: reduce irq-latency after rx overflow

[Manfred Schlaegl]

On 2015-06-22 08:48, Alexander Stein wrote:
> Am Samstag, 20. Juni 2015, 19:25:52 schrieb Manfred Schlaegl:
>> To prevent problems with interrupt latency, and due to the fact, that
>> the error will be counted anyway (icount.overrun), the dev_err is simply
>> removed.
>>
>> Background:
>> If an rx-fifo overflow occurs a dev_err message was called in interrupt
>> context. Since dev_err messages are written to console in a synchronous way
>> (unbuffered), and console may be a serial terminal, this leads to a
>> highly increased interrupt-latency (several milliseconds).
>> As a result of the high latency more rx-fifo overflows will happen, and
>> therefore a feedback loop of errors is created.
> 
> I understand your rationale but removing this error message from kernel log removes the possibility to detect serial overruns by simply check the kernel log or output on kernel console. AFAICS you have to use TIOCGICOUNT to get the error counters.
> How about introducing a rate limit for this kernel message?
> 

Hello!

I understand your argument, but:
 1. In my personal opinion kernel error messages should only be used on internal errors (missing resources, asserts, ...) and in cases where no other way is (yet) available to report errors (by counters, return values, ...). Lost RX bytes on uarts seem more like a communication error and should be silently handled by higher layers using error counters, or protocol internal mechanisms.
 2. I have found no other serial driver (except serial-tegra and imx) that reports this kind of errors using kernel messages.
 3. Error counters for serial interfaces can also be retrieved from userspace by using procfs -> implemented in serial_core; e.g. /proc/tty/driver/IMX-uart.

best regards,
manfred

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature