Re: [PATCH v3 1/2] ext4: Pass in DIO_SKIP_DIO_COUNT flag if inode_dio_begin() called

[Dave Chinner]

On Thu, Apr 14, 2016 at 12:21:13PM -0400, Waiman Long wrote:
> On 04/13/2016 11:16 PM, Dave Chinner wrote:
> >On Tue, Apr 12, 2016 at 02:12:54PM -0400, Waiman Long wrote:
> >>When performing direct I/O, the current ext4 code does
> >>not pass in the DIO_SKIP_DIO_COUNT flag to dax_do_io() or
> >>__blockdev_direct_IO() when inode_dio_begin() has, in fact, been
> >>called. This causes dax_do_io()/__blockdev_direct_IO() to invoke
> >>inode_dio_begin()/inode_dio_end() internally.  This doubling of
> >>inode_dio_begin()/inode_dio_end() calls are wasteful.
> >>
> >>This patch removes the extra internal inode_dio_begin()/inode_dio_end()
> >>calls when those calls are being issued by the caller directly. For
> >>really fast storage systems like NVDIMM, the removal of the extra
> >>inode_dio_begin()/inode_dio_end() can give a meaningful boost to
> >>I/O performance.
> >Doesn't this break truncate IO serialisation?
> >
> >i.e. it appears to me that the ext4 use of inode_dio_begin()/
> >inode_dio_end() does not cover AIO, where the IO is still in flight
> >when submission returns. i.e. the inode_dio_end() call
> >needs to be in IO completion, not in the submitter context. The only
> >reason it doesn't break right now is that the duplicate accounting
> >in the DIO code is correct w.r.t. AIO. Hence bypassing the DIO
> >accounting will cause AIO writes to race with truncate.
> >
> >Same AIO vs truncate problem occurs with the indirect read case you
> >modified to skip the direct IO layer accounting.
> 
> I don't quite understand how the duplicate accounting is correct wrt
> AIO. Both the direct and indirect paths are something like:
> 
>     inode_dio_begin()
>     ...
>         inode_dio_begin()
>         ...
>         inode_dio_end()
>     ...
>     inode_dio_end()

With AIO:

	inode_dio_begin()
	...
		inode_dio_begin()
		<submit IO, no wait>
	...
	inode_dio_end()
<ext4 returns to userspace with AIO+DIO in progress>

<some time later DIO completes>
	        dio_complete
		  inode_dio_end()

IOWs, the ext4 accounting is broken w.r.t. AIO, where IO submission
does not wait for IO completion before returning.

> What the patch does is to eliminate the innermost
> inode_dio_begin/end pair.

Yes, and with that change inode_dio_wait() no longer waits for
AIO+DIO writes on ext4, hence breaking truncate IO barrier
requirements of inode_dio_wait().

Cheers,

Dave.
-- 
Dave Chinner
david@xxxxxxxxxxxxx