Re: [RFC][PATCH 0/6] /dev/random - a new approach

[Nikos Mavrogiannopoulos]

On Thu, Apr 21, 2016 at 5:16 PM, Stephan Mueller <smueller@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>> > ... DRBG is âminimallyâ seeded with 112^6 bits of entropy.
>> > This is commonly achieved even before user space is initiated.
>>
>> Unfortunately one of the issues of the /dev/urandom interface is the
>> fact that it may start providing random numbers even before the
>> seeding is complete. From the above quote, I understand that this
>> issue is not addressed by the new interface. That's a serious
>> limitation (of the current and inherited by the new implementation),
>> since most/all newly deployed systems from "cloud" images generate
>> keys using /dev/urandom (for sshd for example) on boot, and it is
>> unknown to these applications whether they operate with uninitialized
>> seed.
> One more item to consider: If you do not want to change to use getrandom(2),
> the LRNG provides you with another means.

The main problem is not about willing to switch to getrandom() or not,
but finding any system where getrandom() exists. Today due to libc not
having the call, we can only use /dev/urandom and applications would
most likely continue to do so long time after getrandom() is
introduced to libc.

regards,
Nikos