Re: [PATCH 3/6] soc/tegra: pmc: Add support for IO pads power state and voltage

[Jon Hunter]

On 03/05/16 13:31, Laxman Dewangan wrote:
> 
> On Tuesday 03 May 2016 06:04 PM, Jon Hunter wrote:
>> On 02/05/16 13:17, Laxman Dewangan wrote:
>>> +
>>> +    return tegra_io_rail_power_on(dpd_bit);
>>  From a readability standpoint the above seems weird because
>> tegra_io_pads_power_enable() takes an ID as the argument, translates it
>> to a bit value and passes it to tegra_io_rail_power_on() which also
>> takes an ID for the argument.
> 
> Yaah, I did not want to duplicate the implementation and hence it is there.
> We will get rid of the older APIs once this is IN and new mechanism there.
> 
> 
> 
>>> +
>>> +    bval = (io_volt_uv == 3300000) ? BIT(pwr_bit) : 0;
>>> +
>>> +    mutex_lock(&pmc->powergates_lock);
>>> +    tegra_pmc_read_modify_write(PMC_PWR_DET, BIT(pwr_bit),
>>> BIT(pwr_bit));
>>> +    tegra_pmc_read_modify_write(PMC_PWR_DET_VAL, BIT(pwr_bit), bval);
>>> +    mutex_unlock(&pmc->powergates_lock);
>> There are 4 instances of BIT(pwr_bit). May be we should do this once or
>> have tegra_io_pads_to_power_val() return the bit?
> 
> OK, will re-write this part.
> 
> 
>>
>>> +int tegra_io_pads_power_disable(int io_pad_id);
>>> +int tegra_io_pads_power_is_enabled(int io_pad_id);
>> What I don't like here, is now we have two public APIs to do the same
>> job because tegra_io_pads_power_enable/disable() calls
>> tegra_io_rail_power_off/on() internally. Furthermore, the two APIs use
>> different ID definitions to accomplish the same job. This shouldn't be
>> necessary.
> 
> Currently SOR driver is using the tegra_io_rail_power_off/on() APIs.
> Once the proper interface available then I will move sor driver to use
> new method and then we can full get rid of older APIs and macros.
> 
> Till that, we need to have this.

I prefer it is done before this series. In other words, if we need a
proper enum for the rail/pad IDs then add one and convert any existing
drivers over to use any new APIs first. The other option is to live with
the existing API names.

Jon