Re: [PATCH v4 0/5] /dev/random - a new approach

[Stephan Mueller]

Am Montag, 20. Juni 2016, 13:07:32 schrieb Austin S. Hemmelgarn:

Hi Austin,

> On 2016-06-18 12:31, Stephan Mueller wrote:
> > Am Samstag, 18. Juni 2016, 10:44:08 schrieb Theodore Ts'o:
> > 
> > Hi Theodore,
> > 
> >> At the end of the day, with these devices you really badly need a
> >> hardware RNG.  We can't generate randomness out of thin air.  The only
> >> thing you really can do requires user space help, which is to generate
> >> keys lazily, or as late as possible, so you can gather as much entropy
> >> as you can --- and to feed in measurements from the WiFi (RSSI
> >> measurements, MAC addresses seen, etc.)  This won't help much if you
> >> have an FBI van parked outside your house trying to carry out a
> >> TEMPEST attack, but hopefully it provides some protection against a
> >> remote attacker who isn't try to carry out an on-premises attack.
> > 
> > All my measurements on such small systems like MIPS or smaller/older ARMs
> > do not seem to support that statement :-)
> 
> Was this on real hardware, or in a virtual machine/emulator?  Because if
> it's not on real hardware, you're harvesting entropy from the host
> system, not the emulated one.  While I haven't done this with MIPS or
> ARM systems, I've taken similar measurements on SPARC64, x86_64, and
> PPC64 systems comparing real hardware and emulated hardware, and the
> emulated hardware _always_ has higher entropy, even when running the
> emulator on an identical CPU to the one being emulated and using KVM
> acceleration and passing through all the devices possible.
> 
> Even if you were testing on real hardware, I'm still rather dubious, as
> every single test I've ever done on any hardware (SPARC, PPC, x86, ARM,
> and even PA-RISC) indicates that you can't harvest entropy as
> effectively from a smaller CPU compared to a large one, and this effect
> is significantly more pronounced on RISC systems.

It was on real hardware. As part of my Jitter RNG project, I tested all major 
CPUs from small to big -- see Appendix F [1]. For MIPS/ARM, see the trailing 
part of the big table.

[1] http://www.chronox.de/jent/doc/CPU-Jitter-NPTRNG.pdf

Ciao
Stephan