Re: [PATCH 03/13] RTC: ds1307: Add DS1341 specific power-saving options

[Andrey Smirnov]

On Tue, Jun 21, 2016 at 2:07 PM, Alexandre Belloni
<alexandre.belloni@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> On 21/06/2016 at 15:49:04 -0500, Rob Herring wrote :
>> So wouldn't you want to set one mode while running and the lower power
>> mode while suspended? I'm trying to understand the frequency of changing
>> this. If it is always one setting for a board, then yes it belongs in
>> DT. If it is a user decision, then it probably shouldn't be in DT.
>>
>> Seeing as these are reused, I've probably already had this discussion...
>>
>
> I would agree with Rob here. It may be better to provide a sysfs
> interface to configure that particular behavior.

I don't see any value in doing that, could you give me a realistic
example of a scenario in which a user would want to spend some of
uptime with RTC oscillator fault detection/glitch filtering disabled
and then enable it?

> This is usually ok because the use case is:
>  - the RTC is not configured, time has never been set
>  - time is set for the first time
>  - the user can set the oscillator mode/detection/...

Unfortunately exposing that feature using sysfs gives you a leaky
abstraction and your userspace instead of using a generic RTC starts
using DS1341 RTC. So to accommodate for that a user would have to:

a) Write + integrate a userspace tool to set the mode (which IMHO is
decided upon once and doesn't change)
b) If a board design is new and there's a chance of moving this chip
to a different I2C bus, the code above would have to account for that
and not hardcore sysfs path
c) If board's BSP is intended to be used in multiple generations of a
product, not all of which would use DS1341, it would be necessary to
accommodate for that by either more code in the tool or an additional
BSP build configuration variant

>  - on subsequent reboots, the mode is kept alongside the time and date
>

This assumes that your bootloader leaves those mode bits alone.

> I would advise against trying to set a mode automatically in the driver
> because you may have unexpected power cuts and it may then let the RTC
> consume more power than what you really want.
>

I fell like I am not understanding you correctly.  Why would moving
configuration decision logic into userspace improve the situation in
case of unexpected power loss?

Andrey