Re: [RFC PATCH 3/4] x86/asm: Make alternative macro interfaces more clear and consistent

[Andrey Ryabinin]

On 08/31/2017 08:25 PM, Josh Poimboeuf wrote:
>
> There have been a few other ideas which have *almost* worked:
> 
> 1) Make the 'register void *__sp asm(_ASM_SP)' a global variable instead
>    of a local one.  This works for GCC and doesn't break clang.  However
>    it resulted in a lot of changed code on the GCC side.  It looked like
>    some optimizations had been disabled, even in functions which
>    shouldn't have been affected.
> 

(For those who wasn't following previous discussion there is the patch - http://lkml.kernel.org/r/<75850bb7-a60e-057d-d88b-afa0c79e94a0@xxxxxxxxx>
But, Josh discovered that the patch causes regression in .text size with gcc > 7.x
http://lkml.kernel.org/r/<20170721132452.ihpws67e3e7ym3al@treble> )

I'm not so sure that this is disabled optimization. I assume that global rsp makes
changes something in gcc's register allocation logic, or something like that leading
to subtle changes in generated code.

But what I recently find out, is that this "regression" sometimes is actually improvement in .text size.
It all depends on .config, e.g:


allnoconfig:
               text    data     bss     dec     hex filename
patched	       938094  207700 1215752 2361546  2408ca allnoconfig_p/vmlinux
unpatched      938768  211796 1215752 2366316  241b6c allnoconfig/vmlinux                                                                                                                                                         


defconfig:
               text    data     bss     dec     hex filename
patched	       10691469        4882856  876544 16450869         fb0535 defconfig_p/vmlinux
unpatched      10691035        4882856  876544 16450435         fb0383 defconfig/vmlinux

allyesconfig:
               text    data     bss     dec     hex filename
patched	       159216239       153294411       49692672        362203322       1596c8ba        allyesconfig_p/vmlinux
unpatched      159224951       153294387       49692672        362212010       1596eaaa        allyesconfig/vmlinux


So there is regression with Josh's config and defconfig, but allnoconfig and allyesconfig shows improvement.
Note that sometimes there is the difference in .data size too, don't ask me why.

Given that, perhaps the best thing to do here would be asking gcc devs why is generated code changed.
And if such changes are harmless (as I suspect) we can just fix the problem with this simple patch http://lkml.kernel.org/r/<75850bb7-a60e-057d-d88b-afa0c79e94a0@xxxxxxxxx> ?
Despite the increased .text on some configs.