Re: [PATCH] x86: vmx: Allow direct access to MSR_IA32_SPEC_CTRL

[Paolo Bonzini]

On 29/01/2018 09:46, David Woodhouse wrote:
> I'd actually quite like to repeat the benchmark on the new fixed
> microcode, if anyone has it yet, to see if that read/swap slowness is
> still quite as excessive. I'm certainly not ruling this out, but I'm
> just a little wary of premature optimisation, and I'd like to make sure
> we have everything *else* in the KVM patches right first.
> 
> The fact that the save-and-restrict macros I have in the tip of my
> working tree at the moment are horrid and causing 0-day nastygrams,
> probably doesn't help persuade me to favour the approach ;)
> 
> ... hm, the CPU actually has separate MSR save/restore lists for
> entry/exit, doesn't it? Is there any way to sanely make use of that and
> do the restoration manually on vmentry but let it be automatic on
> vmexit, by having it *only* in the guest's MSR-store area to be saved
> on exit and restored on exit, but *not* in the host's MSR-store area?

Right now we don't even use the store-on-vmexit list at all, so the
Simplest Patch That Can Possibly Work is definitely the one using
rdmsr/wrmsr.  It's not really premature optimization---though it doesn't
hurt that it isn't awfully slow.

Paolo