Re: [PATCH 4/7] x86/microcode: Do not upload microcode if CPUs are offline

From: Henrique de Moraes Holschuh
Date: Wed Feb 28 2018 - 08:12:06 EST


On Wed, 28 Feb 2018, Borislav Petkov wrote:
> Avoid loading microcode if any of the CPUs are offline, and issue a
> warning. Having different microcode revisions on the system at any time
> is outright dangerous.

Even if we update that microcode during CPU early bring-up, before we
mark it on-line and start using it?

AFAIK, late-loading or not, this is what should happen in the current
code: APs that are brought up after a microcode update is loaded (either
by the early or late driver, it doesn't matter) will be always
*early-updated* to the new microcode.

Is it dangerous to have an offline core at an older microcode revision
than the online cores?

I am not against the patch, mind you, but I am curious about why it is
supposed to be dangerous if we're updating the CPUs before we start
using them *anyway*.

Also, if this is really dangerous, does it means safe CPU hotplug isn't
possible? AFAICT, the firmware would have to do it for us, but it
*doesn't* have the up-to-date microcode (*we* had to update it)...

--
Henrique Holschuh