Re: [RFC PATCH 4/6] mm: provide generic compat_sys_readahead() implementation

[Al Viro]

On Sun, Mar 18, 2018 at 11:06:42AM -0700, Linus Torvalds wrote:

> and then we can do
> 
>   COMPAT_SYSCALL_DEFINE5(readahead, int, fd,
> COMPAT_ARG_64BIT_ODD(off), compat_size_t, count)
>   {
>       return do_readahead(fd, off_lo + ((u64)off_hi << 64), count);
>   }
> 
> which at least looks reasonably legible, and has *zero* ifdef's anywhere.

It's a bit more complicated, but...

> I do *not* want to see those disgusting __ARCH_WANT_LE_COMPAT_SYS
> things and crazy #ifdef's in code.

Absolutely.  Those piles of ifdefs are unreadable garbage.

> So either let the architectures do their own trivial wrappers
> entirely, or do something clean like the above. Do *not* do
> #ifdef'fery at the system call declaration time.
> 
> Also note that the "ODD" arguments may not be the ones that need
> padding. I could easily see a system call argument numbering scheme
> like
> 
>    r0 - system call number
>    r1 - first argument
>    r2 - second argument
>    ...
> 
> and then it's the *EVEN* 64-bit arguments that would need the padding
> (because they are actually odd in the register numbers). The above
> COMPAT_ARG_64BIT[_ODD]() model allows for that too.
> 
> Of course, if some architecture then has some other arbitrary rules (I
> could see register pairing rules that aren't the usual "even register"
> ones), then such an architecture would really have to have its own
> wrapper, but the above at least would handle the simple cases, and
> doesn't look disgusting to use.

I'd done some digging in that area, will find the notes and post.
Basically, we can even avoid the odd/even annotations and have
COMPAT_SYSCALL_DEFINE... sort it out.  It's a bit more hairy than
I would like at this stage in the cycle, though.  I'll see if it can
be done without too much PITA.

However, there still are genuinely speci^Wfucked in head cases - see
e.g. this sad story:
commit ab8a261ba5e2dd9206da640de5870cc31d568a7c
Author: Helge Deller <deller@xxxxxx>
Date:   Thu Jul 10 18:07:17 2014 +0200

    parisc: fix fanotify_mark() syscall on 32bit compat kernel

Those certainly ought to stay in arch/*