Re: RFC: Using regmap in ARM64 for EL3 register access

[Thor Thayer]

Hi Sudeep,

On 04/04/2018 05:47 AM, Sudeep Holla wrote:
> On 30/03/18 00:00, Thor Thayer wrote:
> > Hi,
> >
> > I'm working on an ARM64 architecture that needs to manipulate some
> > protected registers that are only accessible in EL3. Linux is running at
> > EL1 which doesn't have the proper permissions for these registers.
> If the hardware/IP registers are designed not to provide access to EL1,
> then providing one in software by some means is simply wrong approach to
> solve whatever issue you are trying to address here.
Thank you for the reply!

Sorry, I didn't describe this very well. This mechanism is similar to 
PSCI. We have System Management registers that could be needed by more 
than 1 virtual machine. So arbitration is needed and we use U-Boot for this.

> > Since U-Boot is running at the higher EL3, we communicate to the U-Boot
> > functions through a SMC mechanism.
> Please follow SMCCC to add any SMC interface.
Yes, the existing implementation is doing this and implements a SiP 
service framework.

> > The regmap framework seems like a good match for accessing these
> > registers. We need the same functionality as I2C and SPI regmaps - read,
> > write, and update registers.
> No, providing register access to EL1 using regmap+SMC just defeats the
> hardware security restrictions and may provide ways to exploit.
> Why not abstract to the level of services you need ?
I'm not following about abstracting the level of services. For accessing 
the registers, I thought a regmap implementation would be nice because 
of the read/write/update functionality that would wrap around the SMC 
SiP service functions.

> > Any comments or suggestions about using regmap for this purpose? Is
> > there a better method?
> If you are looking for power management features, then PSCI and SCMI are
> couple of specifications to look at. I would really like to know more
> details on your use case to provide any suggestions.
Thank you for those pointers. I vaguely knew about PSCI but I wasn't 
aware of SCMI. Let me study these interfaces, particularly SCMI, before 
I reply further because this may answer many of my questions.

Thank you again,

Thor