Re: [RFC PATCH v2 3/4] acpi: apei: Do not panic() when correctable errors are marked as fatal.
From: Alex G.
Date: Wed Apr 25 2018 - 11:01:10 EST
On 04/25/2018 09:01 AM, Borislav Petkov wrote:
> On Mon, Apr 23, 2018 at 11:19:25PM -0500, Alex G. wrote:
>> That tells you what FFS said about the error.
> I betcha those status and command values have a human-readable counterparts.
> Btw, what do you abbreviate with "FFS"?
>> It's immediately obvious if there's a glaring FFS bug and if we get bogus
>> data. If you distrust firmware as much as I do, then you will find great
>> value in having such info in the logs. It's probably not too useful to a
>> casual user, but then neither is a majority of the system log.
> No no, you're missing the point - I *want* all data in the error log
> which helps debug a hardware issue. I just want it humanly readable so
> that I don't have to jot down the values and go scour the manuals to map
> what it actually means.
We could probably use more of the native AER print functions, but that's
beyond the scope of this patch. I tried something like this , but
have given up following the PCI maintainer's radio silence. I don't care
_that_ much about the log format.
>> You're missing the timing and assuming you will get the hotplug interrupt.
>> In this example, you have 22ms between the link down and presence detect
>> state change. This is a fairly fast removal.
>> Hotplug dependencies aside (you can have the kernel run without PCIe hotplug
>> support), I don't think you want to just linger in NMI for dozens of
>> milliseconds waiting for presence detect confirmation.
> No, I don't mean that. I mean something like deferred processing:
Like the exact thing that this patch series implements? :)
> get an error, you notice it is a device which supports physical removal
> so you exit the NMI handler and process the error in normal, process
> context which allows you to query the device and say, "Hey device, are
> you still there?"
Like the exact way the AER handler works?
> If it is not, you drop all the hw I/O errors reported for it.
Like the PCI error recovery mechanisms that AER invokes?