Re: Cgroups "pids" controller does not update "pids.current" count immediately

[Ivan Zahariev]

On 14.6.2018 Ð. 18:06 Ñ., Tejun Heo wrote:
> On Thu, Jun 14, 2018 at 02:56:00PM +0300, Ivan Zahariev wrote:
> > I posted a kernel bug about this a month ago but it did not receive
> > any attention: https://bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=199713
> >
> > Here is a copy of the bug report and I hope that this is the correct
> > place to discuss this:
> Well, for now at least, that's the expected behavior.  It's not
> supposed to be able to account all changes immediately (the kernel
> doesn't free a lot of things immediately for performance and other
> reasons).  The intended use is setting up a reasonable upperbound with
> some buffer space.

If that's by design, it's a bit disappointing and at least the docs 
should mention it.

The standard RLIMIT_NPROC does not suffer from such accounting 
discrepancies at any time. The "memory" cgroups controller also does not 
suffer from any discrepancies -- it accounts memory usage in real time 
without any lag on process start or exit. The "tasks" file list is also 
always up-to-date.

Is it really technically not possible to make "pids.current" do 
accounting properly like RLIMIT_NPROC does? We were hoping to replace 
RLIMIT_NPROC with the "pids" controller.

--Ivan