Re: [PATCH v2 01/17] asm: simd context helper API

[Andy Lutomirski]

> On Aug 26, 2018, at 7:18 AM, Jason A. Donenfeld <Jason@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> 
> On Sun, Aug 26, 2018 at 8:06 AM Thomas Gleixner <tglx@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>>> Do you mean to say you intend to make kernel_fpu_end() and
>>> kernel_neon_end() only actually do something upon context switch, but
>>> not when it's actually called? So that multiple calls to
>>> kernel_fpu_begin() and kernel_neon_begin() can be made without
>>> penalty?
>> 
>> On context switch and exit to user. That allows to keep those code pathes
>> fully preemptible. Still twisting my brain around the details.
> 
> Just to make sure we're on the same page, the goal is so that this code:
> 
> kernel_fpu_begin();
> kernel_fpu_end();
> kernel_fpu_begin();
> kernel_fpu_end();
> kernel_fpu_begin();
> kernel_fpu_end();
> kernel_fpu_begin();
> kernel_fpu_end();
> kernel_fpu_begin();
> kernel_fpu_end();
> kernel_fpu_begin();
> kernel_fpu_end();
> ...
> 
> has the same performance as this code:
> 
> kernel_fpu_begin();
> kernel_fpu_end();
> 
> (Unless of course the process is preempted or the like.)
> 
> Currently the present situation makes the performance of the above
> wildly different, since kernel_fpu_end() does something immediately.
> 
> What about something like this:
> - Add a tristate flag connected to task_struct (or in the global fpu
> struct in the case that this happens in irq and there isn't a valid
> current).
> - On kernel_fpu_begin(), if the flag is 0, do the usual expensive
> XSAVE stuff, and set the flag to 1.
> - On kernel_fpu_begin(), if the flag is non-0, just set the flag to 1
> and return.
> - On kernel_fpu_end(), if the flag is non-0, set the flag to 2.
> (Otherwise WARN() or BUG() or something.)
> - On context switch / preemption / etc away from the task, if the flag
> is non-0, XRSTOR and such.

Itâs not that simple. First, these states need names, at least for thinking about. 0 is âuser state in regsâ. 1 is âkernel state activeâ. 2 is ânothing activeâ.

The actual encoding will be something like TIF_XSTATE_UNLOADED: user state is not in regs.  TIF_KERNEL_XSTATE: kernel is using FPU. And this fundamentally doubles the size of struct fpu.

Tglx, that doubling-the-size-of-fpu makes me question the idea of letting the kernel use the fpu while preemptible.

> - On context switch / preemption / etc back to the task, if the flag
> is 1, XSAVE and such. If the flag is 2, set it to 0.
> 



> Jason