X86-64 uses generic string functions (strlen, strchr, memcmp, ...)

From: Jann Horn
Date: Wed Oct 03 2018 - 11:10:56 EST


Hi!

I noticed that X86-64 is using the generic string functions from
lib/string.c for things like strlen(), strchr(), memcmp() and so on.
Is that an intentional omission, because they're not considered worth
optimizing, or is this an oversight? The kernel doesn't use string
functions much, but if you e.g. run readlinkat() in a loop on a
symlink with a 1000-byte target, something around 25%-50% of time are
spent on strlen(). But that's a microbenchmark that people probably
don't care about a lot?

One notable in-kernel user of memcmp() is BPF, which uses it for its
hash table implementations when walking the linked list of a hash
bucket. But I don't know whether anyone uses BPF hash tables with keys
that are sufficiently large to make this noticeable?