Re: [PATCH linux-next v3 6/7] ASoC: rsnd: add avb clocks

[Jiada Wang]

Hi Morimoto-san


On 2018/12/06 14:38, Kuninori Morimoto wrote:
> Hi Jiada
>
> > SMSTPCR922 controls input of two clocks "S0D1Ï" and "S0D4Ï",
> Ahh, OK I could check it via Block diagram.
> But it is "Module stop" for these, anyway.
> "Module stop" and "S0D1Ï/S0D4Ï" are completely different clocks.
Yes, "module stop" is different from "S0D1Ï/S0D4Ï",
both clk_i and avb_counter8's parent clock is same "module stop" clock,
which is <&cpg CPG_MOD 922>, it is a shared gate clock between
avb_counter8 and clk_i


> > "S0D4Ï" is input to BRGA,
> > "S0D1Ï" is input to avb_counter8
> It seems we need to update "clk_i" portion first for this purpose.
> Then, we need to consider about Gen2 vs Gen3, etc, etc...
> It seems we can't keep patch simple...
Yes, I know it's not simple, so I want to discuss with you,
how we can proceed on this topic,
by adding avb_counter8, rcar audio can support arbitrary clock rate,
which is a desired feature, IMO

> > > 3rd, we need to create new clock/handler for
> > > avb_counter8 / audio_clk_div3 / avb_div8 for "internal" purpose,
> > > and need to create avb_adg_syn[] clock for "external" purpose for EAVB/IF.
> > > Your code is creating / registering adg->clkavb[],
> > > but it is for avb_counter8 in my understanding.
> > > We don't need to register it as formal clock IMO.
> > I agree, besides avb_counter8 there are other clocks which need to be
> > added as you have mentioned,
> > in this patch-set, I only added avb_counter8, because I want to keep
> > the patch-set simple,
> > other clocks can be added later.
> No, No, No.
> avb_counter8 is just "internal" clock, and one of
> parent clock for avb_div8 which is needed for avb_adg_syn[].
> We need to control/register is avb_adg_syn[], not avb_counter8.
>
> Your approach on this patch is very "Quick-Hack".
> I have no objection for out-of-tree patches.
> But, "Quick-Hack approach with changing formal DT on upstream"
> is nightmare.
>
> > avb_counter8 is registered as formal clock is because,
> > there is use case that EAVB-IF may use avb_div8, and avb_counter8 is
> > input to avb_div8.
> > if keeps avb_counter8 'internal', I am not sure how EAVB-IF can set
> > clock rate for avb_counter8
> EAVB/IF driver setups avb_adg_syn[].
> Then, ADG considers/searchs avb_counter8/avb_div8/audio_clk_div3
> settings internally.
> Don't control avb_counter8 directly from EAVB.
OK, I think I understand your point,
which avb_counter8 / avb_div8/audio_clk_div3 need to be used,
only need to be considered by adg internally.

Thanks,
Jiada

> Best regards
> ---
> Kuninori Morimoto