Re: [PATCH 3/3] usb: dwc3: gadget: Add support for disabling U1 and U2 entries

[Claus H. Stovgaard]

Hi Anurag

> > > Please use "-" rather than "_" in the property names.
> > I have thought about this feature over the weekend, and think the
> > naming should be
> > changed to something like "snps,bos-u1-exit-lat-in-us"
> > and named the same in the code. And then be the value used by the
> > get_config_params. E.g. the device-tree is used to set the values
> > directly used for
> > bUxdevExitLat instead of named something not related to exit
> > latency.
> > 
> > With this the name and function is a 1 to 1 match, and you can
> > among others set it to
> > 0 for optaining what Anurag wants.
> > 
> Your suggestion looks good but the problem is the U1 and U2 exit
> latencies are
> fixed values in dwc3 controller(can be found in HCSPARAMS3). Adding
> different
> exit latencies may modify the U1SEL/U2SEL values sent from the host
> but the real
> dwc3 controller exit latencies are not getting changed. Because of
> this reason I
> had opted "snps,dis_u1_entry_quirk", so that the U1/U2 exit latency
> values
> reported in BOS descriptor can be either be zero (when U1/U2 entries
> needs to be
> disabled) or non-zero value (reported in HCSPARAMS3) when U1/U2
> states allowed.
> Based on this I think it is better if we can continue with "snps,dis-
> u1-entry-quirk"
> instead of the "snps,bos-u1-exit-lat-in-us". PleaseÂÂprovide your
> opinion on this.

With this in mind I can see why having direct control over the exit
latency value might not be optimum in many situations.
Regarding the name, I think the snps,dis_u1_entry_quirk will be a good
name, if it is combined with the DCTL control. E.g. remove the configfs
part of my patch, and merge the DCTL control with your patches.
If the dt-binding still only control the bos descriptor I think a
better name is something with u1_force_exist_lat_0 or similar.

I don't think setting bos to 0 or controlling DCTL will be used
individual, so to keep things simple I will vote for
snps,dis_u1_entry_quirk, and then just control all elements regarding
disabling U1/U2 from this dt-binding.

Please cut what your need from my patch.

BR Claus