Re: [RFC/PATCH] printk: Fix preferred console selection with multiple matches

[Benjamin Herrenschmidt]

On Wed, 2019-12-11 at 10:17 +0100, Petr Mladek wrote:
> The reverse search of list of console does not work for ttySX
> consoles because the number is omitted when matching. And the messages
> will appear only on the first matched serial console. There is
> a paragraph about this in the commit message of my patch.

About that specific issue...

I see indeed that 8250_core.c registers a "generic" console with index
-1 which will match whetever we hit first in the array.

This is actually wrong isn't it ? Without any change such as what we've
been proposing, it means that an arch doing add_preferred_console of
any ttyS* will override anything on the command line, and it also means
that a command line with multiple ttyS entries will stop at the first
one, not the last one.

IE. In both case the code will select a console that isn't
preferred_console... or am I missing something subtle ?

So yes, fixing that will "regress" in the sense that it will change the
behaviour, but to make it match what's documented... am I wrong ?

The question then becomes what's the most broken ? Changing the
behaviour that might have become expected or leaving the (alledgedly)
broken behaviour in place ?

Cheers,
Ben.