Re: [PATCH net-next] net: dsa: Remove indirect function call for flow dissection

From: Vladimir Oltean
Date: Thu Jan 02 2020 - 19:20:13 EST

Hi Florian,

On Fri, 3 Jan 2020 at 01:39, Florian Fainelli <f.fainelli@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> We only need "static" information to be given for DSA flow dissection,
> so replace the expensive call to .flow_dissect() with an integer giving
> us the offset into the packet array of bytes that we must de-reference

packet array? packed array?

> to obtain the protocol number. The overhead was alreayd available from


> the dsa_device_ops structure so use that directly.
> The presence of a flow_dissect callback used to indicate that the DSA
> tagger supported returning that information,we now encode this with a
> proto_off value of DSA_PROTO_OFF_UNPSEC if the tagger does not support


> providing that information yet.
> Signed-off-by: Florian Fainelli <f.fainelli@xxxxxxxxx>
> ---

Unfortunately I don't really understand the DSA implementations of flow_dissect.
Is proto_off supposed to mean "the __be16 pointer difference A - B
between A. the position of the real EtherType and B. the current
skb->data (aka ETH_HLEN bytes into the frame, aka 2 bytes after the
normal EtherType was supposed to be)"?
Otherwise said, the offset in bytes between the real EtherType
position and skb->data is 2 * (proto_off + 1).
Furthermore, the offset in bytes is exactly equal to the tagger
overhead in bytes, unless it's a tag that doesn't push the EtherType
to the right, such as the trailer tag.

If the above is indeed correct, can you just skip DSA_PROTO_OFF_UNSPEC
and add proper proto_off values "in blind" for all taggers? I think
it's rather safe to assume that they all push the EtherType to the
right with the exception of the trailer tag, which will have an offset
of -1 in terms of __be16 pointers, by the way (so your -1 encoding of
DSA_PROTO_OFF_UNSPEC won't work for it anyway).

Also, documenting the unit of measurement for proto_off would really
go a long way.

What is a good test that the flow_dissector does what it's supposed to
do with DSA?