Re: [PATCH] pinctrl actions: Fix functions groups names

From: Matheus Castello
Date: Fri Jan 24 2020 - 08:43:39 EST

Next message: Naresh Kamboju: "Re: [PATCH 5.4 007/102] libbpf: Fix call relocation offset calculation bug"
Previous message: Mark Brown: "[PATCH] random: Document add_hwgenerator_randomness() with other input functions"
In reply to: Manivannan Sadhasivam: "Re: [PATCH] pinctrl actions: Fix functions groups names"
Next in thread: Matheus Castello: "[PATCH v2] pinctrl: actions: Fix functions groups names"
Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]

Em 1/24/20 9:46 AM, Manivannan Sadhasivam escreveu:

Hey,

+Parthi, who is the author of s700 driver.

On 24 January 2020 8:48:19 AM IST, Matheus Castello <matheus@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Group names by function do not match their respective structures and
documentation defined names.

This fixes following errors observed on s500-based Labrador board when
groups names defined on documentation are used:
[ 4.262778] pinctrl-s700 b01b0040.pinctrl: invalid group
"sd0_d1_mfp" for function "sd0"
[ 4.271394] pinctrl-s700 b01b0040.pinctrl: invalid group
"sd0_d2_d3_mfp" for function "sd0"
[ 4.280248] pinctrl-s700 b01b0040.pinctrl: invalid group
"sd1_d0_d3_mfp" for function "sd0"
[ 4.289122] pinctrl-s700 b01b0040.pinctrl: invalid group
"sd0_cmd_mfp" for function "sd0"

Doh, I'm not sure how I missed this obvious mistake during review. Sorry for that.

The change looks good but the commit message needs to be reworked a bit. It doesn't make sense to use s700 driver on s500 based board. Even though you could've modified it for s500, it should not be mentioned. So just mention the issue. Also you're missing colon after pinctrl in subject.

Ok, I will send a v2.

Btw, are you planning to contribute s500 driver?

Yes I intend to, my research, from a macro view, the pin blocks, groups, registers and functions are quite similar from the s700 to the s500. If so, maybe put a compatible to s500, but still not sure, I have to check it out calmly.

Thanks,
Mani

Fixes: 81c9d563cc74 (pinctrl: actions: Add Actions Semi S700 pinctrl
driver)
Signed-off-by: Matheus Castello <matheus@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
---
drivers/pinctrl/actions/pinctrl-s700.c | 510 ++++++++++++-------------
1 file changed, 255 insertions(+), 255 deletions(-)

diff --git a/drivers/pinctrl/actions/pinctrl-s700.c
b/drivers/pinctrl/actions/pinctrl-s700.c
index 8b8121e35edb..1182b38ff4dc 100644
--- a/drivers/pinctrl/actions/pinctrl-s700.c
+++ b/drivers/pinctrl/actions/pinctrl-s700.c
@@ -1125,317 +1125,317 @@ static const struct owl_pingroup
s700_groups[] = {
};

static const char * const nor_groups[] = {
- "lcd0_d18",
- "i2s_d0",
- "i2s0_pcm0",
- "i2s1_pcm0",
- "i2s_d1",
- "ks_in2",
- "ks_in1",
- "ks_in0",
- "ks_in3",
- "ks_out0",
- "ks_out1",
- "ks_out2",
- "lcd0_d2",
- "lvds_ee_pn",
- "uart2_rx_tx",
- "spi0_i2c_pcm",
- "lvds_e_pn",
- "sd0_d0",
- "sd0_d1",
- "sd0_d2_d3",
- "sd1_d0_d3",
- "sd0_cmd",
- "sd1_cmd",
- "sens0_ckout",
- "sen0_pclk",
+ "lcd0_d18_mfp",
+ "i2s_d0_mfp",
+ "i2s0_pcm0_mfp",
+ "i2s1_pcm0_mfp",
+ "i2s_d1_mfp",
+ "ks_in2_mfp",
+ "ks_in1_mfp",
+ "ks_in0_mfp",
+ "ks_in3_mfp",
+ "ks_out0_mfp",
+ "ks_out1_mfp",
+ "ks_out2_mfp",
+ "lcd0_d2_mfp",
+ "lvds_ee_pn_mfp",
+ "uart2_rx_tx_mfp",
+ "spi0_i2c_pcm_mfp",
+ "lvds_e_pn_mfp",
+ "sd0_d0_mfp",
+ "sd0_d1_mfp",
+ "sd0_d2_d3_mfp",
+ "sd1_d0_d3_mfp",
+ "sd0_cmd_mfp",
+ "sd1_cmd_mfp",
+ "sens0_ckout_mfp",
+ "sen0_pclk_mfp",
};

static const char * const eth_rmii_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_txd23",
- "rgmii_rxd2",
- "rgmii_rxd3",
- "rgmii_txd01",
- "rgmii_txd0",
- "rgmii_txd1",
- "rgmii_txen",
- "rgmii_rxen",
- "rgmii_rxd1",
- "rgmii_rxd0",
- "rgmii_ref_clk",
+ "rgmii_txd23_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd2_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd3_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txd01_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txd0_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txd1_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txen_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxen_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd1_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd0_mfp",
+ "rgmii_ref_clk_mfp",
"eth_smi_dummy",
};

static const char * const eth_smii_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_txd0",
- "rgmii_txd1",
- "rgmii_rxd0",
- "rgmii_rxd1",
- "rgmii_ref_clk",
+ "rgmii_txd0_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txd1_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd0_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd1_mfp",
+ "rgmii_ref_clk_mfp",
"eth_smi_dummy",
};

static const char * const spi0_groups[] = {
- "dsi_dn0",
- "dsi_dp2",
- "dsi_dp0",
- "uart2_rx_tx",
- "spi0_i2c_pcm",
- "dsi_dn2",
+ "dsi_dn0_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp2_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp0_mfp",
+ "uart2_rx_tx_mfp",
+ "spi0_i2c_pcm_mfp",
+ "dsi_dn2_mfp",
};

static const char * const spi1_groups[] = {
- "uart0_rx",
- "uart0_tx",
+ "uart0_rx_mfp",
+ "uart0_tx_mfp",
"i2c0_mfp",
};

static const char * const spi2_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_txd01",
- "rgmii_txd0",
- "rgmii_txd1",
- "rgmii_ref_clk",
- "dnand_acle_ce0",
+ "rgmii_txd01_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txd0_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txd1_mfp",
+ "rgmii_ref_clk_mfp",
+ "dnand_acle_ce0_mfp",
};

static const char * const spi3_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_txen",
- "rgmii_rxen",
- "rgmii_rxd1",
- "rgmii_rxd0",
+ "rgmii_txen_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxen_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd1_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd0_mfp",
};

static const char * const sens0_groups[] = {
- "csi_cn_cp",
- "sens0_ckout",
- "csi_dn_dp",
- "sen0_pclk",
+ "csi_cn_cp_mfp",
+ "sens0_ckout_mfp",
+ "csi_dn_dp_mfp",
+ "sen0_pclk_mfp",
};

static const char * const sens1_groups[] = {
- "lcd0_d18",
- "ks_in2",
- "ks_in1",
- "ks_in0",
- "ks_in3",
- "ks_out0",
- "ks_out1",
- "ks_out2",
- "sens0_ckout",
- "pcm1_in",
- "pcm1_clk",
- "pcm1_sync",
- "pcm1_out",
+ "lcd0_d18_mfp",
+ "ks_in2_mfp",
+ "ks_in1_mfp",
+ "ks_in0_mfp",
+ "ks_in3_mfp",
+ "ks_out0_mfp",
+ "ks_out1_mfp",
+ "ks_out2_mfp",
+ "sens0_ckout_mfp",
+ "pcm1_in_mfp",
+ "pcm1_clk_mfp",
+ "pcm1_sync_mfp",
+ "pcm1_out_mfp",
};

static const char * const uart0_groups[] = {
- "uart2_rtsb",
- "uart2_ctsb",
- "uart0_rx",
- "uart0_tx",
+ "uart2_rtsb_mfp",
+ "uart2_ctsb_mfp",
+ "uart0_rx_mfp",
+ "uart0_tx_mfp",
};

static const char * const uart1_groups[] = {
- "sd0_d2_d3",
+ "sd0_d2_d3_mfp",
"i2c0_mfp",
};

static const char * const uart2_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_txen",
- "rgmii_rxen",
- "rgmii_rxd1",
- "rgmii_rxd0",
- "dsi_dn0",
- "dsi_dp2",
- "dsi_dp0",
- "uart2_rx_tx",
- "dsi_dn2",
- "uart2_rtsb",
- "uart2_ctsb",
- "sd0_d0",
- "sd0_d1",
- "sd0_d2_d3",
- "uart0_rx",
- "uart0_tx",
+ "rgmii_txen_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxen_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd1_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd0_mfp",
+ "dsi_dn0_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp2_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp0_mfp",
+ "uart2_rx_tx_mfp",
+ "dsi_dn2_mfp",
+ "uart2_rtsb_mfp",
+ "uart2_ctsb_mfp",
+ "sd0_d0_mfp",
+ "sd0_d1_mfp",
+ "sd0_d2_d3_mfp",
+ "uart0_rx_mfp",
+ "uart0_tx_mfp",
"i2c0_mfp",
"uart2_dummy"
};

static const char * const uart3_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_txd23",
- "rgmii_rxd2",
- "rgmii_rxd3",
- "uart3_rtsb",
- "uart3_ctsb",
+ "rgmii_txd23_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd2_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd3_mfp",
+ "uart3_rtsb_mfp",
+ "uart3_ctsb_mfp",
"uart3_dummy"
};

static const char * const uart4_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_txd01",
- "rgmii_ref_clk",
- "ks_out0",
- "ks_out1",
+ "rgmii_txd01_mfp",
+ "rgmii_ref_clk_mfp",
+ "ks_out0_mfp",
+ "ks_out1_mfp",
};

static const char * const uart5_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_rxd1",
- "rgmii_rxd0",
- "ks_out0",
- "ks_out2",
- "uart3_rtsb",
- "uart3_ctsb",
- "sd0_d0",
- "sd0_d1",
+ "rgmii_rxd1_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd0_mfp",
+ "ks_out0_mfp",
+ "ks_out2_mfp",
+ "uart3_rtsb_mfp",
+ "uart3_ctsb_mfp",
+ "sd0_d0_mfp",
+ "sd0_d1_mfp",
};

static const char * const uart6_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_txd0",
- "rgmii_txd1",
+ "rgmii_txd0_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txd1_mfp",
};

static const char * const i2s0_groups[] = {
- "i2s_d0",
- "i2s_pcm1",
- "i2s0_pcm0",
+ "i2s_d0_mfp",
+ "i2s_pcm1_mfp",
+ "i2s0_pcm0_mfp",
};

static const char * const i2s1_groups[] = {
- "i2s1_pcm0",
- "i2s_d1",
+ "i2s1_pcm0_mfp",
+ "i2s_d1_mfp",
"i2s1_dummy",
- "spi0_i2c_pcm",
- "uart0_rx",
- "uart0_tx",
+ "spi0_i2c_pcm_mfp",
+ "uart0_rx_mfp",
+ "uart0_tx_mfp",
};

static const char * const pcm1_groups[] = {
- "i2s_pcm1",
- "spi0_i2c_pcm",
- "uart0_rx",
- "uart0_tx",
- "pcm1_in",
- "pcm1_clk",
- "pcm1_sync",
- "pcm1_out",
+ "i2s_pcm1_mfp",
+ "spi0_i2c_pcm_mfp",
+ "uart0_rx_mfp",
+ "uart0_tx_mfp",
+ "pcm1_in_mfp",
+ "pcm1_clk_mfp",
+ "pcm1_sync_mfp",
+ "pcm1_out_mfp",
};

static const char * const pcm0_groups[] = {
- "i2s0_pcm0",
- "i2s1_pcm0",
- "uart2_rx_tx",
- "spi0_i2c_pcm",
+ "i2s0_pcm0_mfp",
+ "i2s1_pcm0_mfp",
+ "uart2_rx_tx_mfp",
+ "spi0_i2c_pcm_mfp",
};

static const char * const ks_groups[] = {
- "ks_in2",
- "ks_in1",
- "ks_in0",
- "ks_in3",
- "ks_out0",
- "ks_out1",
- "ks_out2",
+ "ks_in2_mfp",
+ "ks_in1_mfp",
+ "ks_in0_mfp",
+ "ks_in3_mfp",
+ "ks_out0_mfp",
+ "ks_out1_mfp",
+ "ks_out2_mfp",
};

static const char * const jtag_groups[] = {
- "ks_in2",
- "ks_in1",
- "ks_in0",
- "ks_in3",
- "ks_out1",
- "sd0_d0",
- "sd0_d2_d3",
- "sd0_cmd",
- "sd0_clk",
+ "ks_in2_mfp",
+ "ks_in1_mfp",
+ "ks_in0_mfp",
+ "ks_in3_mfp",
+ "ks_out1_mfp",
+ "sd0_d0_mfp",
+ "sd0_d2_d3_mfp",
+ "sd0_cmd_mfp",
+ "sd0_clk_mfp",
};

static const char * const pwm0_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_rxd2",
- "rgmii_txen",
- "ks_in2",
- "sen0_pclk",
+ "rgmii_rxd2_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txen_mfp",
+ "ks_in2_mfp",
+ "sen0_pclk_mfp",
};

static const char * const pwm1_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_rxen",
- "ks_in1",
- "ks_in3",
- "sens0_ckout",
+ "rgmii_rxen_mfp",
+ "ks_in1_mfp",
+ "ks_in3_mfp",
+ "sens0_ckout_mfp",
};

static const char * const pwm2_groups[] = {
- "lcd0_d18",
- "rgmii_rxd3",
- "rgmii_rxd1",
- "ks_out0",
- "ks_out2",
+ "lcd0_d18_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd3_mfp",
+ "rgmii_rxd1_mfp",
+ "ks_out0_mfp",
+ "ks_out2_mfp",
};

static const char * const pwm3_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_rxd0",
- "ks_out1",
- "lcd0_d2",
+ "rgmii_rxd0_mfp",
+ "ks_out1_mfp",
+ "lcd0_d2_mfp",
};

static const char * const pwm4_groups[] = {
- "lcd0_d18",
- "rgmii_txd01",
- "rgmii_txd0",
- "ks_in0",
- "pcm1_in",
- "nand_ceb3",
+ "lcd0_d18_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txd01_mfp",
+ "rgmii_txd0_mfp",
+ "ks_in0_mfp",
+ "pcm1_in_mfp",
+ "nand_ceb3_mfp",
};

static const char * const pwm5_groups[] = {
- "rgmii_txd1",
- "ks_in1",
- "pcm1_clk",
- "nand_ceb2",
+ "rgmii_txd1_mfp",
+ "ks_in1_mfp",
+ "pcm1_clk_mfp",
+ "nand_ceb2_mfp",
};

static const char * const p0_groups[] = {
- "ks_in2",
- "ks_in0",
+ "ks_in2_mfp",
+ "ks_in0_mfp",
};

static const char * const sd0_groups[] = {
- "ks_out0",
- "ks_out1",
- "ks_out2",
- "lcd0_d2",
- "dsi_dp3",
- "dsi_dp0",
- "sd0_d0",
- "sd0_d1",
- "sd0_d2_d3",
- "sd1_d0_d3",
- "sd0_cmd",
- "sd0_clk",
+ "ks_out0_mfp",
+ "ks_out1_mfp",
+ "ks_out2_mfp",
+ "lcd0_d2_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp3_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp0_mfp",
+ "sd0_d0_mfp",
+ "sd0_d1_mfp",
+ "sd0_d2_d3_mfp",
+ "sd1_d0_d3_mfp",
+ "sd0_cmd_mfp",
+ "sd0_clk_mfp",
};

static const char * const sd1_groups[] = {
- "dsi_dp2",
- "mfp1_16_14",
- "lcd0_d2",
- "mfp1_16_14_d17",
- "dsi_dp3",
- "dsi_dn3",
- "dsi_dnp1_cp_d2",
- "dsi_dnp1_cp_d17",
- "dsi_dn2",
- "sd1_d0_d3",
- "sd1_cmd",
+ "dsi_dp2_mfp",
+ "mfp1_16_14_mfp",
+ "lcd0_d2_mfp",
+ "mfp1_16_14_d17_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp3_mfp",
+ "dsi_dn3_mfp",
+ "dsi_dnp1_cp_d2_mfp",
+ "dsi_dnp1_cp_d17_mfp",
+ "dsi_dn2_mfp",
+ "sd1_d0_d3_mfp",
+ "sd1_cmd_mfp",
"sd1_dummy",
};

static const char * const sd2_groups[] = {
- "dnand_data_wr",
+ "dnand_data_wr_mfp",
};

static const char * const i2c0_groups[] = {
- "uart0_rx",
- "uart0_tx",
- "i2c0_mfp",
+ "uart0_rx_mfp",
+ "uart0_tx_mfp",
+ "i2c0_mfp_mfp",
};

static const char * const i2c1_groups[] = {
@@ -1448,85 +1448,85 @@ static const char * const i2c2_groups[] = {
};

static const char * const i2c3_groups[] = {
- "uart2_rx_tx",
- "pcm1_sync",
- "pcm1_out",
+ "uart2_rx_tx_mfp",
+ "pcm1_sync_mfp",
+ "pcm1_out_mfp",
};

static const char * const lvds_groups[] = {
- "lvds_o_pn",
- "lvds_ee_pn",
- "lvds_e_pn",
+ "lvds_o_pn_mfp",
+ "lvds_ee_pn_mfp",
+ "lvds_e_pn_mfp",
};

static const char * const bt_groups[] = {
- "i2s_pcm1",
- "i2s0_pcm0",
- "i2s1_pcm0",
- "ks_in2",
- "ks_in1",
- "ks_in0",
- "ks_in3",
- "ks_out0",
- "ks_out1",
- "ks_out2",
- "lvds_o_pn",
- "lvds_ee_pn",
- "pcm1_in",
- "pcm1_clk",
- "pcm1_sync",
- "pcm1_out",
+ "i2s_pcm1_mfp",
+ "i2s0_pcm0_mfp",
+ "i2s1_pcm0_mfp",
+ "ks_in2_mfp",
+ "ks_in1_mfp",
+ "ks_in0_mfp",
+ "ks_in3_mfp",
+ "ks_out0_mfp",
+ "ks_out1_mfp",
+ "ks_out2_mfp",
+ "lvds_o_pn_mfp",
+ "lvds_ee_pn_mfp",
+ "pcm1_in_mfp",
+ "pcm1_clk_mfp",
+ "pcm1_sync_mfp",
+ "pcm1_out_mfp",
};

static const char * const lcd0_groups[] = {
- "lcd0_d18",
- "lcd0_d2",
- "mfp1_16_14_d17",
- "lvds_o_pn",
- "dsi_dp3",
- "dsi_dn3",
- "lvds_ee_pn",
- "dsi_dnp1_cp_d2",
- "dsi_dnp1_cp_d17",
- "lvds_e_pn",
+ "lcd0_d18_mfp",
+ "lcd0_d2_mfp",
+ "mfp1_16_14_d17_mfp",
+ "lvds_o_pn_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp3_mfp",
+ "dsi_dn3_mfp",
+ "lvds_ee_pn_mfp",
+ "dsi_dnp1_cp_d2_mfp",
+ "dsi_dnp1_cp_d17_mfp",
+ "lvds_e_pn_mfp",
};

static const char * const usb30_groups[] = {
- "ks_in1",
+ "ks_in1_mfp",
};

static const char * const clko_25m_groups[] = {
- "clko_25m",
+ "clko_25m_mfp",
};

static const char * const mipi_csi_groups[] = {
- "csi_cn_cp",
- "csi_dn_dp",
+ "csi_cn_cp_mfp",
+ "csi_dn_dp_mfp",
};

static const char * const dsi_groups[] = {
- "dsi_dn0",
- "dsi_dp2",
- "dsi_dp3",
- "dsi_dn3",
- "dsi_dp0",
- "dsi_dnp1_cp_d2",
- "dsi_dnp1_cp_d17",
- "dsi_dn2",
+ "dsi_dn0_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp2_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp3_mfp",
+ "dsi_dn3_mfp",
+ "dsi_dp0_mfp",
+ "dsi_dnp1_cp_d2_mfp",
+ "dsi_dnp1_cp_d17_mfp",
+ "dsi_dn2_mfp",
"dsi_dummy",
};

static const char * const nand_groups[] = {
- "dnand_data_wr",
- "dnand_acle_ce0",
- "nand_ceb2",
- "nand_ceb3",
+ "dnand_data_wr_mfp",
+ "dnand_acle_ce0_mfp",
+ "nand_ceb2_mfp",
+ "nand_ceb3_mfp",
"nand_dummy",
};

static const char * const spdif_groups[] = {
- "uart0_tx",
+ "uart0_tx_mfp",
};

static const char * const sirq0_groups[] = {

Next message: Naresh Kamboju: "Re: [PATCH 5.4 007/102] libbpf: Fix call relocation offset calculation bug"
Previous message: Mark Brown: "[PATCH] random: Document add_hwgenerator_randomness() with other input functions"
In reply to: Manivannan Sadhasivam: "Re: [PATCH] pinctrl actions: Fix functions groups names"
Next in thread: Matheus Castello: "[PATCH v2] pinctrl: actions: Fix functions groups names"
Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]