Re: [PATCH v5 1/3] net: introduce helper sendpage_ok() in include/linux/net.h

[Christoph Hellwig]

On Sun, Aug 16, 2020 at 10:55:09AM -0700, Cong Wang wrote:
> On Sun, Aug 16, 2020 at 1:36 AM Coly Li <colyli@xxxxxxx> wrote:
> >
> > The original problem was from nvme-over-tcp code, who mistakenly uses
> > kernel_sendpage() to send pages allocated by __get_free_pages() without
> > __GFP_COMP flag. Such pages don't have refcount (page_count is 0) on
> > tail pages, sending them by kernel_sendpage() may trigger a kernel panic
> > from a corrupted kernel heap, because these pages are incorrectly freed
> > in network stack as page_count 0 pages.
> >
> > This patch introduces a helper sendpage_ok(), it returns true if the
> > checking page,
> > - is not slab page: PageSlab(page) is false.
> > - has page refcount: page_count(page) is not zero
> >
> > All drivers who want to send page to remote end by kernel_sendpage()
> > may use this helper to check whether the page is OK. If the helper does
> > not return true, the driver should try other non sendpage method (e.g.
> > sock_no_sendpage()) to handle the page.
> 
> Can we leave this helper to mm subsystem?
> 
> I know it is for sendpage, but its implementation is all about some
> mm details and its two callers do not belong to net subsystem either.
> 
> Think this in another way: who would fix it if it is buggy? I bet mm people
> should. ;)

No.  This is all about a really unusual imitation in sendpage, which
is pretty much unexpected.  In fact the best thing would be to make
sock_sendpage do the right thing and call sock_no_sendpage based
on this condition, so that driver writers don't have to worry at all.