Re: [PATCH] tpm_tis: Disable interrupts on ThinkPad T490s

[Hans de Goede]

Hi,

On 10/16/20 12:39 AM, Matthew Garrett wrote:
> On Thu, Oct 15, 2020 at 2:44 PM Jerry Snitselaar <jsnitsel@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> > There is a misconfiguration in the bios of the gpio pin used for the
> > interrupt in the T490s. When interrupts are enabled in the tpm_tis
> > driver code this results in an interrupt storm. This was initially
> > reported when we attempted to enable the interrupt code in the tpm_tis
> > driver, which previously wasn't setting a flag to enable it. Due to
> > the reports of the interrupt storm that code was reverted and we went back
> > to polling instead of using interrupts. Now that we know the T490s problem
> > is a firmware issue, add code to check if the system is a T490s and
> > disable interrupts if that is the case. This will allow us to enable
> > interrupts for everyone else. If the user has a fixed bios they can
> > force the enabling of interrupts with tpm_tis.interrupts=1 on the
> > kernel command line.
>
> I think an implication of this is that systems haven't been
> well-tested with interrupts enabled. In general when we've found a
> firmware issue in one place it ends up happening elsewhere as well, so
> it wouldn't surprise me if there are other machines that will also be
> unhappy with interrupts enabled. Would it be possible to automatically
> detect this case (eg, if we get more than a certain number of
> interrupts in a certain timeframe immediately after enabling the
> interrupt) and automatically fall back to polling in that case? It
> would also mean that users with fixed firmware wouldn't need to pass a
> parameter.

IIRC then at least on the T490 the irq storm caused systems to not boot
in some cases. I guess if we detect the storm and disable the irq we might
fix that... OTOH this problem seems to only hit a certain generation of
Thinkpads so with some luck the denylist should not be too big and the denylist
approach should work.

Regards,

Hans