Re: [PATCH v2] Adding i2c-cp2615: i2c support for Silicon Labs' CP2615 Digital Audio Bridge

[Wolfram Sang]

Hi Bence,

> You are right, sorry, I am still familiarizing myself with `git send-email`

No worries, the progress from your first to your second version was
really great! You can add such information e.g. using the "--annotate"
parameter og git-send-email.

> GPLv2 or later is fine by me. If I change this to "//
> SPDX-License-Identifier: GPL-2.0-or-later", is that OK?

Yes, also perfect.

> > > + * FIXME: There in no quirk flag for specifying that the adapter
> > > + * does not support empty transfers, or that it cannot emit a
> >
> > Can't we use I2C_AQ_NO_ZERO_LEN here?
> 
> I thought that meant the adapter cannot handle NEITHER zero-length
> reads NOR writes, but the CP2615 can do a zero read combined with a
> non-zero write or the other way around, just both cannot be zero. If
> both are zero, the chip just ignores the request, as I've learned from
> a very confusing situation with `i2cdetect`.

I think we still should use I2C_AQ_NO_ZERO_LEN. The almost only use case
is a standalone zero-len read or write. This is not supported by your
adapter as you found out.

> > True! But it makes sense, so we can fix that. We just need to add
> > I2C_AQ_NO_REP_START and a short explanation to i2c.h. If you want, you
> > can do it in a seperate patch. I can do it, too, if you prefer.
> 
> Sure! I should just define it as BIT(7) or something, right? Should I
> do it in a completely different patchset, or is it OK if I submit it
> as the 2/2 of PATCH v3? Are there maybe other adapters that would be

Yes, BIT(7) and same patchset please. But you need to make it 1/2
because you will use it in you driver which is then 2/2.

> affected?

Maybe, but we can fix them later incrementally. Currently, there is also
no client testing the flag, so we have a bit of time here.

> > Maybe skip the defines for VID and PID and use the values directly?
> > I am not a USB expert, not really sure what the consistent way is.
> 
> I think this is how they usually do it, or at least from what I've seen.

Then keep it.

All the best and happy hacking,

   Wolfram

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: PGP signature