Re: [PATCH] spi: bcm2835: Fix buffer overflow with CS able to go beyond limit.

[Mark Brown]

On Fri, Apr 23, 2021 at 11:03:22AM +0100, Joe Burmeister wrote:
> On 23/04/2021 00:49, Florian Fainelli wrote:

> > Right, which means that we should probably seek a solution within the
> > SPI core itself, even if you can only test with spi-bcm2835.c chances
> > are that the fix would be applicable for other controllers if done in
> > the core.

> I'm not sure it's possible to do in the core alone. The numb of the
> issue is the core changes ctlr->num_chipselect to what is in the device
> tree and some drivers are cool with that overs quietly stomp memory.

I wouldn't expect any controller to be OK with that?  Drivers can store
per-client data in spi_device->controller_data which doesn't need
scaling (but is also not so helpful if you need to look at clients other
than the one you're currently controlling).

> I've got a simple little patch to warn when the core expands
> ctlr->num_chipselect. This warning won't go off in bcm2835 with my patch
> because I am also extending ctlr->num_chipselect to the amount in the
> device tree before the core does that expansion. Hopefully that new
> warning would make people investigate and fix problem drivers.

> >> There is protection in spi_add_device, which will catch extra added
> >> later, but not ones in the device tree when the spi controller was
> >> registered.

> > Not sure I follow you, if we have the overlay before
> > spi_register_controller() is called, how can the check there not
> > trigger? And if we load the overlay later when the SPI controller is
> > already registered, why does not spi_add_device()'s check work?

> I think it might be a RPI thing. I think it is merging in the overlay
> and giving Linux one already merged.

If the overlay is handled by the bootloader then from the point of view
of Linux there is no overlay - sounds like there's an issue in the
overlay, it should be overriding something that it doesn't?

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: PGP signature