Re: [PATCH v6 0/1] asus-wmi: Add support for custom fan curves

[Hans de Goede]

Hi Luke,

On 8/29/21 9:14 AM, Luke D. Jones wrote:
> Add support for custom fan curves found on some ASUS ROG laptops.
> 
> - V1
>   + Initial patch work
> - V2
>   + Don't fail and remove wmi driver if error from
>     asus_wmi_evaluate_method_buf() if error is -ENODEV
> - V3
>   + Store the "default" fan curves
>   + Call throttle_thermal_policy_write() if a curve is erased to ensure
>     that the factory default for a profile is applied again
> - V4
>   + Do not apply default curves by default. Testers have found that the
>     default curves don't quite match actual no-curve behaviours
>   + Add method to enable/disable curves for each profile
> - V5
>   + Remove an unrequired function left over from previous iterations
>   + Ensure default curves are applied if user writes " " to a curve path
>   + Rename "active_fan_curve_profiles" to "enabled_fan_curve_profiles" to
>     better reflect the behavious of this setting
>   + Move throttle_thermal_policy_write_*pu_curves() and rename to
>     fan_curve_*pu_write()
>   + Merge fan_curve_check_valid() and fan_curve_write()
>   + Remove some leftover debug statements
> - V6
>   + Refactor data structs to store  array or u8 instead of strings.
>     This affects the entire patch except the enabled_fan_curves block
>   + Use sysfs_match_string in enabled_fan_curve block
>   + Add some extra comments to describe things
>   + Allow some variation in how fan curve input can be formatted
>   + Use SENSOR_DEVICE_ATTR_2_RW() to reduce the amount of lines per
>     fan+profile combo drastically

Thank you for your continued work on this. I read in the discussin of v5
that you discussed using the standard auto_point#_pwm, auto_point#_temp
pairs. I see here that you have decided to not go that route, may I ask
why ?

Regards,

Hans