Re: [PATCH v4 1/4] MIPS: Refactor early_parse_mem() to fix mem= parameter

[Maciej W. Rozycki]

On Fri, 4 Mar 2022, Thomas Bogendoerfer wrote:

> > > With this patch, when add "mem=3G" to the command-line, the
> > > kernel boots successfully, we can see the following messages:
> > 
> > unfortunately this patch would break platforms without memory detection,
> > which simply use mem=32M for memory configuration. Not sure how many
> > rely on this mechanism. If we can make sure nobody uses it, I'm fine
> > with your patch.
> 
> maybe we could add a CONFIG option, which will be selected by
> platforms, which don't need/want this usermem thing.

 FWIW I don't understand what the issue is here beyond that we have a bug 
that causes a system to hang when "mem=3G" is passed on the kernel command 
line.  That is assuming that system does have contiguous RAM available for 
the kernel to use from address 0 up to 3GiB; otherwise it's a user error 
to tell the kernel it has that memory available (I did get bitten by that 
myself too): garbage in, garbage out.

 I think having a CONFIG option automatically selected to disable the 
ability to give a memory map override would handicap people in debugging 
their systems or working around firmware bugs, so I would rather be 
against it.

  Maciej