RE: [PATCH] RAS/CEC: Reduce default threshold to offline a page to "2"

[Luck, Tony]

>> Existing default is 1023 ... which is not a good choice for anyone (except
>> perhaps ostriches that want to bury their heads in the sand an ignore marginal
>> DIMMs for as long as possible).
>
>Why isn't that a good choice?

It fails to use the capabilities of h/w an Linux to avoid a fatal error in the future.
Corrected errors are (sometimes) a predictor of marginal/aging memory. Copying
data out of a failing page while there are just corrected errors can avoid losing
that whole page later.

A single error is plausibly a particle strike causing a bit flip. But a second error
in the same page is a long shot (my desktop has 64G of memory, so 16 million
pages ... that's an awful lot of other targets for a second particle strike).

>I'm sure there are error rates where this fits just fine.

Explain further. Apart from the "ostrich" case I'm not sure what they are.

>> So changing the threshold to "2" would be an improvement in at least
>> being right for one vendor, instead of wrong for all.
>
>So I'm pretty sure that is not needed on AMD at all.

It's far more a property of DIMMs than of the CPU. Unless AMD are using
some DECTED or better level of ECC for memory.

-Tony