Re: [PATCH RFC] cpumask: Randomly distribute the tasks within affinity mask

[Andy Shevchenko]

On Wed, Oct 11, 2023 at 12:49:25PM +0530, Ankit Jain wrote:
> commit 46a87b3851f0 ("sched/core: Distribute tasks within affinity masks")
> and commit 14e292f8d453 ("sched,rt: Use cpumask_any*_distribute()")
> introduced the logic to distribute the tasks at initial wakeup on cpus
> where load balancing works poorly or disabled at all (isolated cpus).
> 
> There are cases in which the distribution of tasks
> that are spawned on isolcpus does not happen properly.
> In production deployment, initial wakeup of tasks spawn from
> housekeeping cpus to isolcpus[nohz_full cpu] happens on first cpu
> within isolcpus range instead of distributed across isolcpus.
> 
> Usage of distribute_cpu_mask_prev from one processes group,
> will clobber previous value of another or other groups and vice-versa.
> 
> When housekeeping cpus spawn multiple child tasks to wakeup on
> isolcpus[nohz_full cpu], using cpusets.cpus/sched_setaffinity(),
> distribution is currently performed based on per-cpu
> distribute_cpu_mask_prev counter.
> At the same time, on housekeeping cpus there are percpu
> bounded timers interrupt/rcu threads and other system/user tasks
> would be running with affinity as housekeeping cpus. In a real-life
> environment, housekeeping cpus are much fewer and are too much loaded.
> So, distribute_cpu_mask_prev value from these tasks impacts
> the offset value for the tasks spawning to wakeup on isolcpus and
> thus most of the tasks end up waking up on first cpu within the
> isolcpus set.
> 
> Steps to reproduce:
> Kernel cmdline parameters:
> isolcpus=2-5 skew_tick=1 nohz=on nohz_full=2-5
> rcu_nocbs=2-5 rcu_nocb_poll idle=poll irqaffinity=0-1
> 
> * pid=$(echo $$)
> * taskset -pc 0 $pid
> * cat loop-normal.c
> int main(void)
> {
>         while (1)
>                 ;
>         return 0;
> }
> * gcc -o loop-normal loop-normal.c
> * for i in {1..50}; do ./loop-normal & done
> * pids=$(ps -a | grep loop-normal | cut -d' ' -f5)
> * for i in $pids; do taskset -pc 2-5 $i ; done
> 
> Expected output:
> * All 50 “loop-normal” tasks should wake up on cpu2-5
> equally distributed.
> * ps -eLo cpuid,pid,tid,ppid,cls,psr,cls,cmd | grep "^    [2345]"
> 
> Actual output:
> * All 50 “loop-normal” tasks got woken up on cpu2 only
> 
> Analysis:
> There are percpu bounded timer interrupt/rcu threads activities
> going on every few microseconds on housekeeping cpus, exercising
> find_lowest_rq() -> cpumask_any_and_distribute()/cpumask_any_distribute()
> So, per cpu variable distribute_cpu_mask_prev for housekeeping cpus
> keep on getting set to housekeeping cpus. Bash/docker processes
> are sharing same per cpu variable as they run on housekeeping cpus.
> Thus intersection of clobbered distribute_cpu_mask_prev and
> new mask(isolcpus) return always first cpu within the new mask(isolcpus)
> in accordance to the logic mentioned in commits above.
> 
> Fix the issue by using random cores out of the applicable CPU set
> instead of relying on distribute_cpu_mask_prev.

> Fixes: 46a87b3851f0 ("sched/core: Distribute tasks within affinity masks")
> Fixes: 14e292f8d453 ("sched,rt: Use cpumask_any*_distribute()")

> 

Blank lines are not allowed in the tag block.

> Signed-off-by: Ankit Jain <ankitja@xxxxxxxxxx>

...

> +/**
> + * Returns an arbitrary cpu within srcp.
> + *
> + * Iterated calls using the same srcp will be randomly distributed
> + */

This is invalid. Always run

	scripts/kernel-doc -v -none -Wall ...

against the file of interest and fix all warnings and errors reported.

-- 
With Best Regards,
Andy Shevchenko