Re: [PATCH 06/16] iommu/dma: use page allocation function provided by iommu-pages.h

[Robin Murphy]

On 2023-11-28 10:50 pm, Pasha Tatashin wrote:
> On Tue, Nov 28, 2023 at 5:34 PM Robin Murphy <robin.murphy@xxxxxxx> wrote:
> > On 2023-11-28 8:49 pm, Pasha Tatashin wrote:
> > > Convert iommu/dma-iommu.c to use the new page allocation functions
> > > provided in iommu-pages.h.
> >
> > These have nothing to do with IOMMU pagetables, they are DMA buffers and
> > they belong to whoever called the corresponding dma_alloc_* function.
>
> Hi Robin,
>
> This is true, however, we want to account and observe the pages
> allocated by IOMMU subsystem for DMA buffers, as they are essentially
> unmovable locked pages. Should we separate IOMMU memory from KVM
> memory all together and add another field to /proc/meminfo, something
> like "iommu -> iommu pagetable and dma memory", or do we want to
> export DMA memory separately from IOMMU page tables?

These are not allocated by "the IOMMU subsystem", they are allocated by 
the DMA API. Even if you want to claim that a driver pinning memory via 
iommu_dma_ops is somehow different from the same driver pinning the same 
amount of memory via dma-direct when iommu.passthrough=1, it's still 
nonsense because you're failing to account the pages which iommu_dma_ops 
gets from CMA, dma_common_alloc_pages(), dynamic SWIOTLB, the various 
pools, and so on.

Thanks,
Robin.

> Since, I included DMA memory, I specifically removed mentioning of
> IOMMU page tables in the most of places, and only report it as IOMMU
> memory. However, since it is still bundled together with SecPageTables
> it can be confusing.
>
> Pasha