Re: [PATCH 1/1] x86/mm/pae: Align up pteval_t, pmdval_t and pudval_t to avoid split locks

[Sean Christopherson]

On Thu, Apr 04, 2024, Dave Hansen wrote:
> On 4/4/24 08:26, Sean Christopherson wrote:
> > In other words, practically speaking this isn't about supporting a new hardware
> > feature on 32-bit kernels, it's about preserving performance in real world
> > scenarios when running 32-bit kernels on new hardware.
> 
> Realistically, most of the 32-bit kernels in the world are going to be
> *OLD* distros, right?  Old CentOS/RHEL/SLES kernels from before the
> kernel had split lock detection, or split lock fixes.  Those trip over
> VMM split lock detection now, and presumably will forever.
> 
> I suspect new CentOS/RHEL/SLES kernels that have split lock detection
> all happened after 32-bit support was dropped from those distros.
> 
> I think that basically leaves Debian.  Someone would need to:
> 
>  1. Make a *new* 32-bit Debian distro install (or one of the other
>     less common distros that still do 32-bit)
>  2. Run it on hardware with split lock detection
>  3. On a VMM that enables split lock detection
>  4. Stay close enough to mainline to get split lock fixes (like from
>     this thread)
>  5. Care about performance, despite *ACTIVELY* choosing a 32-bit distro
>     on 64-bit hardware in 2024
>
> Those steps are certainly possible.  I'm just not sure how much trouble
> we want to go to in 2024 to support people that choose new 32-bit
> distros and desire performance.

I'm worried about a scenario where the throttling is so bad that it's not a perf
issue, but a functional issue ("performance" was a bad choice of word).

I do agree that the probability of this being a real problem is super low, but at
the same time it doesn't seem too onerous to clean up.  And in the unlikely case
that this does cause a problem, the pain on our end can be quite high.

> It feels to me to be approaching "I want a pony" territory.
> 
> Or am I just lacking empathy today? :)

Nah, I'm probably asking for a pony, but AFAICT it's a pretty cheap pony.