iio: dac: ad5624r_spi.c - use of scan_type
From: Matti Vaittinen
Date: Wed Dec 18 2024 - 03:38:53 EST
Hi dee Ho peeps,
I started drafting a driver for a ROHM DAC. I took a quick look at the
ad5624r_spi.c, and the use of the 'scan_type' -field in the struct
iio_chan_spec puzzled me.
I think this field is used by the driver to convert the data from user
to register format while performing the INDIO_DIRECT_MODE raw writes. I
don't spot any buffer usage. Furthermore, as far as I can say the 'sign'
and 'storagebits' are unused.
My understanding has been that the scan_type is only intended for
parsing the buffered values, and usually when the data direction is from
driver to user.
I suppose I shouldn't copy the ad5624r_spi.c use of scan_type to a new
driver. I'm somewhat tempted to send a patch which drops the scan_type
from the ad5624r_spi.c, and adds the 'realbits' and 'shift' to the
driver's internal struct ad5624r_state. This, however, will change the
interface to userland so maybe it's best to not do that.
I wonder if I am missing something? (That wouldn't be unheard of XD). If
not, then at least a documentary patch with a comment "don't do this in
new drivers" might be Ok, or how do you see this?
Yours,
-- Matti