Re: [PATCH] PCI: Add D3cold reset quirk for devices with broken/missing FLR

[Jose Ignacio Tornos Martinez]

Hello Alex,

> We should not have driver dependent reset behavior.  If FLR is broken,
> add these devices to the list of devices using quirk_no_flr() and we'll
> fall back to another reset method.  We also shouldn't be implementing a
> variant of pci_pm_reset().  PM reset can also be prioritized over FLR
> via the reset_methods sysfs attribute if the reset method really is
> tied to the usage.  Thanks,
Thank you for your feedback and help

I tested quirk_no_flr() and it works perfectly for mt7925e. The related                                                                                                                                            
mt7922e device was already in that list so this was expected.

However, for the Qualcomm devices, that solution doesn't work and they
need a different approach.

So, I will submit two independent patches for v2: one for mt7925e following
your suggestion with quirk_no_flr(), and another for Qualcomm devices with a
different proposal trying to follow the same idea.

Best regards
José Ignacio