Re: [RFC PATCH] scsi: ufs: core: Allow error recovery before the device W-LUN exists

[Peter Wang]

On Mon, 2026-11-02 at 02:36 +0200, Asdlerto Korry wrote:
> ufshcd_err_handling_should_stop() returns true while hba-
> >ufs_device_wlun
> is NULL, i.e. until the first probe has added the device W-LUN. If
> the
> link fails during that first probe (for example NOP OUT failing after
> link startup), the error handler therefore never resets the host or
> the
> link: it only marks the state operational and returns, and the probe
> keeps failing until it gives up.
> 
> On a Samsung Galaxy M52 5G (SM7325) the first link startup regularly
> ends in PA errors (LINERESET). With the W-LUN check removed, the
> error
> handler performs a real host reset and restore and the device comes
> up;
> without it, it never does.

Hi Asdlerto,

I’m a bit curious why the first link startup fails, while 
the link startup after a reset and restore doesn’t. 
Shouldn’t these two flows be identical? 
I think the driver is designed on the assumption that the 
basic init must succeed, and that only a re-init can make 
recovery possible.

Thanks.
Peter