Re: [PATCH] mm/vma: restore VMA iterator on full-range merge failure

From: shao.mingyin

Date: Sat Nov 14 2026 - 13:58:57 EST


Hi Lorenzo,

Thank you for taking the time to review these patches. I am sorry for
interrupting your work and for the unnecessary review effort caused by
the iterator report.

I checked the mprotect() caller again. You are right: when the VMA is
revisited, its flags have already been updated and mprotect_fixup()
returns without changing them again. My added assertion established an
iterator position change, not a functional failure. I have withdrawn
that patch.

Since you also raised the breadth of my submissions in the related
threads (https://lore.kernel.org/all/avibe0HG4ssUUuBX@gremlin/), I
checked my submission records to provide some per-subsystem context.
Below are selected subsystems with recorded Reviewed-by or Applied
outcomes through 14 November (UTC+8). Patches first submitted on
15 November are excluded. Each distinct patch is counted once, including
fixes and cleanups; revisions, resends, cover letters and discussion
replies are not counted again.

Subsystem Sent Reviewed-by Applied Withdrawn
NVMe/nvmet 19 11 7 0
UBIFS 12 6 0 0
ATA 18 5 7 1
GPIO 5 3 0 1
target 8 2 5 0
SCSI 9 2 3 1
ublk 5 2 0 0
PCI 5 1 1 0
MFD 7 1 0 0
ALSA/ASoC 5 0 5 0
SPI 5 0 5 0

"Reviewed-by" counts patches with that explicit review tag. "Applied"
means merged or explicitly applied by a maintainer. A patch can appear
in both columns. "Withdrawn" includes patches I withdrew after review.

For two concrete examples of accepted work:

https://git.kernel.org/linus/08a6572441a4e646c96c2b8d8ead9eea0e458332
https://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/mkp/scsi.git/commit/?id=fe5988e8708e1d42cb844bd9ac8f0a51388061fc

The first fixes zone-append sector reporting in virtio-blk's polled
completion path; the second fixes a NULL dereference in target ALUA.
These independently reviewed or accepted fixes are why I believe
AI-assisted work can make useful contributions. I remain responsible
for understanding each report and for the correctness of each patch.

I would like to learn from the technical feedback and improve the
quality of my contributions. Thank you for any further guidance you
are willing to offer, and again, sorry for the interruption.

Thanks,
Shao